the previous one bothered me because it was shorter than most avatars making the header of the forum look weird
Didn't see that coming.When I first saw that new logo,I was suprised.Overall,looks better,so make that the current logo.
@IcedI was thinking the same thing.Main thing is that the I and M lining up are making the separation more obvious.
Gate Man said, May 15, 2009, 10:54:28 pmFor some reason, now I can't remember how the old one looked like.
sucks indeed the other one looked much more proffesional, this is just some kidz-coolz typo with some zomg surfer background, i emphasize the made up words to let u guys know the feeling it gives
The F being smaller than the M now makes it look kinda off IMO.EDIT: Maybe bringing the "ighters" closer to the F would be better.
Think it would look good if you extended the top of the F and made the word Mugen attached to it?Kinda looks like a game show logo. But I think it looks better than the old one too.[size=5pt]Don't forget you said you'd make one for "The Devon Legacy" when/if you found time ^^[/size]
Makkah said, May 15, 2009, 11:06:42 pmThe F being smaller than the M now makes it look kinda off IMO.I think it looks fine. The font stays consistent with each other ie the size in each line.
QuoteDon't forget you said you'd make one for "The Devon Legacy" when/if you found time ^^yeah i haven't forgotten, it's not so much lack of time but lack of ideas. i'll try something soon.okay fags pick oneA:B:C:D:
B or D is fine. To be honest I never really recognized the old logo when visiting the forum because it seemed so tame. New design stands out and makes MFG the official home of mugen messege board hysteria.
For the "F" flip to work well I think it needs to lean the same direction as the rest of the fonts.C or D, C since more people are leaning that way.
Titiln said, May 15, 2009, 11:22:53 pmhttp://i40.tinypic.com/30tmccj.pngLOL.Thats funny.Also,I think D.
Titiln said, May 15, 2009, 11:17:56 pmD:This one is the best.Never thought you can design. Nice job Tit(-)lin.
I don't like C. 'Fighters' shouldn't have to compromise by being extended more towards the left. The blue oval isn't occupied as much by the text as it should be. Then again, I don't B or D because I hate text starting with a giant capitol followed by lower case capitols.
#Shaun said, May 15, 2009, 11:44:09 pmThen again, I don't B or D because I hate text starting with a giant capitol followed by lower case capitols. that doesn't happen in b though????
Titiln said, May 15, 2009, 11:48:20 pm#Shaun said, May 15, 2009, 11:44:09 pmThen again, I don't B or D because I hate text starting with a giant capitol followed by lower case capitols. that doesn't happen in b though????shit i meant c
I see upsides to all of B, C and D, so it's hard...B: The only one where all letters of each word really belong together. Could you make it with the "fighters" text more centered so that the F isn't the only letter outside the background?C: Err... coolD: Probably the best arrangement, but then has a three-letter gang bang
The new logo looks cool! The old just just feels bland.But it reminds me of Screwattack.com's logo.....
I see what you mean when you said it looked strange with the F and I so close together. I'd say to add some space between the F and I in the third one but then they would form the letter A.
The new logo looks better. It gives the site a more video game like feel. Titiln said, May 15, 2009, 11:17:56 pmokay fags pick oneA:http://i40.tinypic.com/2w73kuu.pngB:http://i41.tinypic.com/2r7tqvk.pngC:http://i39.tinypic.com/34yza5c.pngD:http://i39.tinypic.com/16ao2g3.pngIn my opinion, I prefer C.
c it is... but wait??? walt wanted to see what it'd look like with the previous banner's background and i kinda like itc: c2: How does this Guild logo look
Titiln said, May 15, 2009, 10:47:18 pmi tried putting the f closer and it looked weirdermaybe i could make it smaller HMMMMaybe try extending the second horizontal line in the F.
Titiln, the guy who types in all lowercase made GUILD in all caps and capitalized the 'F' in Fighters.
The new logo is quite awesome. As much as I liked the WWF Smackdown!-reminiscent logo, this one seems better suited for a fighting game forum.
PotS said, May 16, 2009, 03:23:32 amC1 looks clean like the rest of the forum.that's quite a strong argument..
The C1 Logobut the BG in C2 draws less attention to the logo, it almost look like something you see in a kaleidoscope.But yes, I feel The C1 one logo needs a bg of some sort, the logo itself is dynamic I applaud you for that but perhaps a simple bg?OMG did I say simple? anyway just my 2 cents if it matters any...
Castanet Master Yui said, May 16, 2009, 08:04:31 amIt's better to have what the original logo has.I don't really see a reason for that. There have been a few logos on Guild already, and they didn't need that.
How about merging C1 and C2 together so generally it's C2 with paler BG (like 50% opacity)?The logo is not really being one thing with the header now. It's more like it's standing out.
Quotesucks indeed the other one looked much more proffesional,I work with logos all day and I can tell you: the old wasn't "proffesional". At all.I like the new logo, good work.edit: The C1 version is a lot better. There is rule which says that a logo COULD applied in anyware and can't have a background.
That just screams Halloween right there.Also you screwed up the borders. GIF doesn't have an alpha channel like PNG.
randomish said, May 16, 2009, 03:28:35 pmhttp://i589.photobucket.com/albums/ss335/TheEditors/MFG.gifColor Scheme is way off and its basically a hue and saturation adjustment and the edges were transparent for a reason you know.Anyway yeah I am sticking to C1 but still it fell like something is missingPerhaps the I just have to adjust and get used to the logo for it to grow on me.
-SyN- said, May 16, 2009, 03:46:55 pmrandomish said, May 16, 2009, 03:28:35 pmhttp://i589.photobucket.com/albums/ss335/TheEditors/MFG.gifColor Scheme is way off and its basically a hue and saturation adjustment and the edges were transparent for a reason you know.Anyway yeah I am sticking to C1 but still it fell like something is missingPerhaps the I just have to adjust and get used to the logo for it to grow on me.what?i just like the way it looks
-SyN- said, May 16, 2009, 11:31:29 amOMG did I say simple? Who are you and what have you done with SyN? I dont like any of them, start over.Seriously, the extended part of the F does distract from the rest of the banner. Even though the E and L are also extended. Possibly because the font size isn't consistant? So, I dont like any of them, start over.
so c it is. valodim please change it TIAthe background variant could be used for banners or a screenpack though HMMMMthanks for the input everybody!
Titiln said, May 16, 2009, 06:36:47 pmthe background variant could be used for banners or a screenpack though HMMMMHA!
DooM said, May 16, 2009, 02:22:57 pmHow about merging C1 and C2 together so generally it's C2 with paler BG (like 50% opacity)?I like what you're thinking
randomish said, May 16, 2009, 03:28:35 pmhttp://i589.photobucket.com/albums/ss335/TheEditors/MFG.gifOnly for Halloween
[V]yn said, May 15, 2009, 10:58:43 pmsucks indeed the other one looked much more proffesional, this is just some kidz-coolz typo with some zomg surfer background, i emphasize the made up words to let u guys know the feeling it givesIt's the fonts. I'm not digging them.
Hey Titiln, good job fuckface. I like C2 better. If you can somehow give it more depth so that the blue cage thing looks like it's in the background and doesn't distract you from the letters, it'll work.There's something about it just floating there in the white space that feels weird.It begs for something to be on the right side of the screen. Putting the background will make it more definitive where it is.
Cloudius said, May 16, 2009, 08:30:43 pmrandomish said, May 16, 2009, 03:28:35 pmhttp://i589.photobucket.com/albums/ss335/TheEditors/MFG.gifOnly for Halloweenlol
