The Mugen Fighters Guild

Forum Particulars => Feedback => Topic started by: krudelu on January 28, 2017, 05:22:26 pm

Title: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: krudelu on January 28, 2017, 05:22:26 pm: Hello,

I've been playing around with tweaking some characters for a while just for fun so I'm getting some motivation to try to make a character little by little in the past despite not deciding to really start on it.

Recently, due to a certain sprite rip release, I became more motivated to try making a character so I'm now starting to make one.

Despite me trying to make a character, I'm still at learning stage. Since I've been making some progress, I want to be able to ask for critique/feedback when I get certain parts done so I can try to improve step by step.

Is there a certain thread where I can make such post?
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: ShinZankuro on January 28, 2017, 05:24:33 pm: You normally can show your sprite works creating your own thread on that section of the forum. (http://mugenguild.com/forum/graphics.340)

EDIT: Depending of the style of the sprite you are making, you can show single ones on a specific style thread[CPS2, CPS3, CVS, SNK, etc.. There's a Master List where you can found the thread style you are used to make :)

http://mugenguild.com/forum/topics/master-list-theme-threads-commissions-graphics-arts-hof-etc--150903.0.html )
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: Speedpreacher on January 28, 2017, 05:28:52 pm: If you're just looking to spitball some ideas, make a thread in Idea Engineering.

If your character is at the point where you've got it running in MUGEN, make a thread in Projects and put some open betas out if you want critique.

Once the character's in a releasable state (i.e. hopefully not a horribly buggy punching bag) make a thread in Releases.
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: krudelu on January 28, 2017, 05:34:27 pm: Well in my case I'm using sprites that are ripped by someone already so I'm putting them now and having it run in MUGEN.

For now, I got certain animations aligned and some clsn work. I wanted to get critique on my current progress. Would that be good enough to be posted at the project thread? Or Idea engineering?
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: Speedpreacher on January 28, 2017, 05:48:28 pm: Sounds more like you're looking for some Development Help, but if your character's at the point where you can make a video or take some screenshots of it running in MUGEN you can post it in Projects.
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: krudelu on January 28, 2017, 06:01:00 pm: So would it be good to post about asking for critique/feedback/thought regarding my current sprites alignment and CLSN works in the development thread then? I'm also planning to make a DL for it for people to be able to check it.
Title: Re: Question about a place to post for asking for critique
Post by: Iced on January 30, 2017, 04:18:54 pm: That would make the most sense yes.
If you are happy with how it goes and want to release it or proceed with the work then it would become a project and a release.