Board: Hall of Fame
He knows his way around the Net and had pointed out that japanese pages were having a working WinMUGEN hack up (the 1) for download, even before the banning spree here and elsewhere occured, warning us of what would come.
Anyway, back to the 20th of June, where I contacted him shortly after the above chat sessions. He always kinda exaggerates, y'know "2 days, 2 weeks, 2 months, never", and this time he said he was getting closer. He had been able to push the limit up to 9 characters; the same thing had been done on some Japanese page, according to him.
I trust him so far that I don't believe he was making that up, and so we had more hackers closing in on the limit, and one already out. That's the reference to "stopping" them.
Expectation had it that once this no limit leaked through to MGBR, well, nothing pretty would occur.
Turned out that was not the case. Okay, everyone now uses it, but it is not "supported". Same as with the 1 hack.
There was nothing FORCED. Nobody HAD to do anything.
The most efficient way was Dev (and Blargh). Assumption was that MGBR anyway and also Guild would follow suite.
Need for efficiency was there because we wanted to do this BEFORE it leaked through unaltered.
Clearly MGBR would not qualify as efficient - but nor would Guild.
Winane was contacted, but his "I'll try to talk to someone I think was part of Elecbyte . . . next weekend, or the weekend afer that, or . . ." was ignored as we wanted to make haste.
It still took ages until finally someone sat down and actually DID something, like writing some e-mail or organizing anythig.
Going to Guild with it was out of question. Contacting members not, but was not really done either, right.
Of all the people that were contacted, all agreed, one did not care, and Winane, who did not post yes or no as I recall, but I'm not sure.
Still, that left 10+ guys (sorry, lost track) in agreement with this. By now, that number is obviously higher. A lot.
Dreamslayer:
Great point. Personally, I had my shock moment when the 1 hack spread - as had many others.
I had started thinking about how to deal with the 1 hack in the future some time ago, because I had actually considered it as an example of problematic moral/ethic decissions in one of my final school exams. Anyway.
Forum politics aside, what is the earlier mentioned "harm"?
WinMUGE for everyone, and unlimited. Why not? I know I would of used it anyway. Wouldn't you have, had you been aware of it?
What is the harm in "officially" using it?
The people who agreed with this before announcing it were mostly old creators. Are you accusing them of disrespecting Elecbyte? Do you really think this it what happened? We dropped our respect?
Then your "patience" is greater than ours.
Some months ago, I could not have imagined "losing hope" or something. We don't know for a fact that Elecbyte is dead; but they are certainly not present, and have not been for a long time.
And that, I think, is essentially the only valuable point and question we could clearly see (apart from the background of the illegal):
Whether Elecbyte might still be around despite everything, or might soon be again.
Amazingly, the overwhelming feeling towards this was an almost certain No. And all that felt worth taking the risk.
And that's it.
And in all these posts, especially the newer ones, I cannot see any other intelligent point concerning the core question. It's petty board politics, and It Was That Way - No Not At All, You Lose - But You Blah. [The second being especially painful to read.]
That's what I meant you should try to avoid here.
"Justification" and pointless Right About This Point, Wrong About That One discussions.
We were and are convinced we did the Right Thing, as "illegal" as it might be. If you are convinced we did the Wrong Thing, that's okay. But both positions would have a hard time standing up in court, seeing how we don't have real fact- or law-based arguments.
Quote
"Sith? Jedi?" she said. "Are these the only choices? Dark or light, good or evil? Is there no more to the Force than this? What is the screen on which light and dark cast their shapes and shadows? Where is the ground on which stands good and evil?"







) so Rou Hei would get all the info brought to him there...