YesNoOk

Show content

This section allows you to browse the content for this member. Note that you can only see content for which you have sufficient viewing permissions.

**
MugoUrth is Offline
Contact MugoUrth:

MugoUrth

User

Messages by MugoUrth

    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 23, 2012, 02:53:23 am View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

mugo is a new regular at mffa I know you said not to derail but I have to call darkflare out on this.

We do not worship crap characters Hosting them and liking them are 2 different things.

I am the Main Mod of the site and I can tell you most of us do not like half the crap we post. Its posted for anyone else who might like it. We have a collections section that is probably the best area on the site, with links to different games complete rosters and such or even franchises Like nippon ichis games. we well most of us like GOOD characters not crap.

the reason you never hear good things "here anyways" is because warehousing is looked down upon here and thats what the sites goal is.

ANYWAY, ontopic Mugo they are correct this character is badly coded the eoh template is a horrible thing to use, NEVER should you use a template to make a character ever. IMT is full of broken terrible characters so is CVG. he's not making this up they are really bad.

Eh, I guess I am starting to notice more of the problems in the character. I still kind of like it, but I am starting to see where the complaints come from.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 11:06:30 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 11:00:10 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

Actually, no. MFFA, for starters.

Mugen Free for all? Isn't that the place with the little kids who worship any character based on a cartoon regardless of how bad it is?

Those guys have no right to be calling out people as not being Mugen experts(which quite honestly, is rather amusing in itself), because they sure as hell aren't.

Oh, wow. You're absolutely right. Those guys basically worship people like Wlanmania and Ivan Luiz, and other really awful MUGEN creators.

...Seriously, you have no idea what you're talking about. They barely have good things to say about Madoldcrow. (Who is average at absolute best in terms of making Mugen Characters.) But like most Mugenites, they really look up to people like Seanalty. (Who's really GOOD at making Mugen characters. ...Although I kind of think his Solid Snake is slightly overrated.)

And even then, it's not just MFFA. Pretty much every other place I've seen, too.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 10:51:46 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

Because "it uses a quote-on-quote flawed template" and "it's not real MvC style" are real reasons.
Well, it's just that at this point the EoH template has been so picked apart that no one really sees the need to restate exactly why it's bad. Basara did a pretty good job here explaining why.

Also, in a lot of forums I go to, the people their complain that the people at Mugen Fighters Guild aren't exactly the Mugen Experts they claim to be.
I don't think anyone is claiming to be a MUGEN expert; instead I think what we have here (in this particular thread) are people very familiar with MvC, people who know how MvC plays and how characters based on that style of gameplay should play like if they are to be labeled "MvC". Characters made using the EoH template are, more often than not, pretty bad. They play somewhat like MvC, but only on the surface. If one probes deeply, they'll find EoH characters very lacking. MvC is probably one of the hardest gameplay styles to emulate, because there are so many things going on at once.

Ah, I guess that makes sense. Like I did mention, I noticed Chill's combo-ing abilities were not accurate to the style, as well as a few other problems as well. Maybe I'm easier to please than you guys.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 10:46:12 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

I know he explained it a little bit. I wasn't implying he didn't. I was mostly implying that everyone else wasn't. But even then, I STILL say you're being strict about it. Like, what is a good MUGEN character to you guys?
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 10:38:39 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

I can say you by personal experience: EoH template not just isn't accurate to MVC games, also plays bad in MUGEN, has a lot of infinites, overuses MVC2 elements (A LOT) and has other major flaws that make everything created under this template in a big NONO. In YouTube there're a lot of videos about characters with this template (since IMT's MVC fullgame to new creators making chars with this) showing how bad they are, even various users here got videos about that, Arpa included... who also made a joke character (MVC EoH C.Evil Ryu) who reveals all the flaws it has this template.

Resuming, EoH is simply bad and any char made with this template is a good reason to stay away from it

That's fine if someone actually EXPLAINS it. But I still like the character. I'm not saying it's a masterpiece, only that you guys are being a bit strict without explaining yourself well.

I really didn't notice any infinites with Chill Penguin.
I noticed the comboing was a bit off, but big deal.
Certain attacks aimed at the ice sculptures can sometimes harm Chill as well, but it's not something I notice all that often.

Again, I'm not saying it's an amazing character everyone should like, just that it's not as bad as you guys are making it out to be.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 10:26:47 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

The hell you talking about? Arpa clearly showed GOOD reason why it sucks so bad.

Because "it uses a quote-on-quote flawed template" and "it's not real MvC style" are real reasons.

Would these forums happen to be CvG or IMT?

Actually, no. MFFA, for starters.

Seriously, respect to be respected, MugoUrth. If you find that character is good, no problem. If someone else find it bad, okey, too. You can't make someone likes the character you like. Also, Arpa is well-known for make good critics to characters...

Unless you're MugenPlayer21 and don't want to hear criticism about your character

Again, it's not that. It's just that he isn't actually saying WHY it sucks. If he actually gave reasons instead of saying "Oh it uses a template, it's not accurate to MvC, bawwww," I'd be okay with it. Also, he's not actually giving criticism. That's just it. I'd have nothing wrong with him disliking the character, it's just that he seems biased about it.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 10:13:02 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

I don't really understand why he's making an argument at all. Alpa only said that it's a poorly-coded character-- which is true. He's stating a fact. he's not INSULTING the guy who made it. If you like it, cool. But is he in the wrong because he's not lying and saying "This character is great!" to keep from hurting people's feelings?

It has more to do with the fact that he doesn't have any GOOD reason as to why it sucks so bad?

What are my counter-arguments? Well, sue me, I like it. I think it's well balanced, it's fun to play as, it's not overpowering yet you can still kick butt with it, yet it still takes skill to use. Sure, you COULD spam projectiles if you're a noob, but they're not infinite trapping projectiles. I thought his gameplay, overall, was pretty well made.

Also, in a lot of forums I go to, the people their complain that the people at Mugen Fighters Guild aren't exactly the Mugen Experts they claim to be. I've made several reasons as to why I like the character, but I have yet to hear any actual reasons as to why Alpa doesn't like it. It's mostly just "Oh it uses a template," and "it isn't 100% perfect template," and so on.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 09:51:32 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

Or perhaps it's because I know the difference between a good and a bad marvel vs capcom character and you don't.

No, you're just being picky.

You know, since, I actually have a good enough idea as to how Marvel vs Capcom works to know that using the EoH template guarantees that your character cannot be good you are seriously better off making your character from scratch.

Okay, then. Tell us what exactly is WRONG with it, then. Saying "it sucks" or "It uses a template" doesn't say anything.

I also know my basic fighting game fundamentals enough to know this is not how you do a super

So a Mugen Character doesn't do a quarter life-bar's worth of damage every super, so that means it's poorly coded. This character's got enough moves and combo-potential to make up for his lack of power without being cheap.

"Not perfect" does not excuse that it's poorly coded in my opinion.

Also, constantly saying it's poorly coded without post WHY it's poorly coded won't help someone get better at making MUGEN characters. Have you ever tried criticism?

Take it from me. Just give up now. Look up Rogue's topic here to see how well this works out. I'm sure someone will give useful critique soon enough.

Yeah, I've talked with people like him. They ALWAYS stick to their guns. I'm not going to win this one.
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 09:17:13 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

Or perhaps it's because I know the difference between a good and a bad marvel vs capcom character and you don't.

No, you're just being picky.

You know, since, I actually have a good enough idea as to how Marvel vs Capcom works to know that using the EoH template guarantees that your character cannot be good you are seriously better off making your character from scratch.

Okay, then. Tell us what exactly is WRONG with it, then. Saying "it sucks" or "It uses a template" doesn't say anything.

I also know my basic fighting game fundamentals enough to know this is not how you do a super

So a Mugen Character doesn't do a quarter life-bar's worth of damage every super, so that means it's poorly coded. This character's got enough moves and combo-potential to make up for his lack of power without being cheap.

"Not perfect" does not excuse that it's poorly coded in my opinion.

Also, constantly saying it's poorly coded without post WHY it's poorly coded won't help someone get better at making MUGEN characters. Have you ever tried criticism?
    

Re: Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21

 June 22, 2012, 07:54:47 pm View in topic context
 Posted by MugoUrth  in Chill Penguin (MvC) by MugenPlayer21 (Started by Magma Dragoon MK II June 21, 2012, 04:06:31 pm
 Board: Found Releases

Are we using the same MUGEN Character? I thought it was pretty good. It's nicely balanced, and is pretty on character, overall fun to play. Sure, it's not perfect, but I think what you said was kind of out of bounds, Alpa.

Hey Magma, off topic but I really like your avie. I remember that part in Crimson Room.