Eased Falcone's pain If there was a third option of waiting for Falcone to start talking before injecting the morphine, I would've taken it, but just giving him morphine right away is close enough, I guess.
Tried to kiss Selina Batman has to kiss Catwoman. It's practically teleological! And she just said she wasn't actually in a relationship with Harvey Dent, so... Batman's only human!!!
Visited the mayor as Bruce Wayne gotta keep Batman's image intact. Plus, it'd be easier to ask certain questions as Bruce, and going as Bruce theoretically left the option of visiting Hill as Batman later on down the line.
Continued to fund Harvey's campaign I didn't really have any qualms about Harvey trashing the Wayne's public image, but I was concerned about the possibility of the truth about his campaign financing coming out later. Ultimately I felt like had to go with the risky strategy of continuing to fund him, because the alternative seemed to be Hill getting another term.
Saved Selina instead of Harvey Catwoman was about to be surrounded by 3 armed goons, which is a lot more dangerous than having someone about to throw a stage light on your head; true, Harvey was in a potentially lethal situation, but Catwoman was in absolutely certain mortal peril. There was a good chance Harvey could survive (and he did!), but I Catwoman's fate looked sealed if I save her.
and like, c'mon. There was practically a giant neon sign hanging above Harvey saying "THIS IS HOW HE BECOMES TWO-FACE". Couldn't let Batman stand in the way of that!
here are the extra choices listed on Telltale's website, but not the game itself:
I didn't forgive Alfred this is a bit misleading sounding, because there were three choices: immediately forgive Alfred, refuse to forgive him, or say you need more time. I chose the latter. Obviously Batman should forgive Alfred at some point, but I just can't see him totally forgiving Alfred for lying for 2 decades straight.
Told Harvey why I wanted to see Falcone couldn't really see a reason why not?
Withheld Montoya's name from Vicki Vale no way would I give up Montoya before the facts were all in. Not only would it be a huge violation of trust between Bruce and Harvey/Gordon, it'd also be very damaging to Montoya herself. She's clearly been set up, and if her name got out in the wild so quickly, it could severely damage any hope of proving her innocence.
I refused to make a deal with Mayor Hill Maaaaaaaan, fuck that asshole.
I'm not sure if I forgot, or I picked a conversation path that skipped over this, but when did Batman learn that Cobblepot also goes by the name Penguin?
I'm still on the fence about the revelations about the Wayne family. I think Thomas Wayne secretly working with the unsavory elements of Gotham could maybe work for this version of Batman, but that video of him basically injecting the Penguin's mom with LIQUID INSANITY was really beyond the pale. There's no way that could even be remotely justified, even from an ends-justify-the-means sorta way. Obviously there's still 3 episodes to go, but I'm still pretty unsure about where this plotline is going.
also please please please do not let the leader of the Children of Arkham turn out to be the Joker. Just use someone else, or invent someone new. This doesn't really fit the Joker anyways! And there's been more than enough plots where he's revealed to be the secret masked mastermind, and it's getting really old!
Please.