The Mugen Fighters Guild - Carlos the Stickman by Josh Geary

Download: http://www.mediafire.com/download/ay9uh7yse3ld238/Carlos+The+Stickman.zip

Spoiler: Personal Feedback (Applies to Gajardo the Stickman V1.1 only, not Carlos) (click to see content)

Horrible collision boxes, over 10 of them in some cases, with spacing between the char's legs and highlighting zones that do not matter
Has zero range or priority on most of his normals
Severe case of lack of chaining, notable because there's an attempt at an air combo launcher, Old Daniel could chain his attacks properly somewhat, so why can't this guy do so?
Normals don't seem to have much advantages nor disadvantages to them, 2Z is too safe, while for some reason 2C isn't, and just like Old Daniel, he has two launchers, instead of having one crouch move destined as a sweep for the style he seems to be going for (in this case, Based on Old Daniel, he's trying to "hybrid CvS with MvC")
2A can be blockable high, this should not be the case
Voice gets annoying real quick
I don't think j.5C or j.5Z look like overheads
QCF+A AND QCB+A both whiff on point blank against training
QCB+A has a ton of negative frame advantage despite being a move with a big start up
Can't do "EX Projectile", he must have put the command detection for it below the normal projectile.
Perhaps QCBx2+Y is too safe and too meaty (too long active frames) for a fullscreen slam attack. Not sure if it should be blockable high either, as it attacks from below, super BG dissapears too late.
QCB+X's helper seems useless, just like WlanmaniaX's kind of helpers, I don't think a helper slowly walking and dealing a lousy normal attack is a good idea for a helper either. I'd reccomend a helper that does something as an special move that appears quick, sorta like compared to MvC's assists that can be used and then need to recharge after a short while, that's a better kind if you ask me
Why does this thing have Homer's voice in some of his supers, also QCF+X+Y is safe on block, when it shouldn't as it makes it spammy, also 304 is too much damage for a level 1, since P2 will take the fall damage value as Gajardo is in pose animation, which still has the red hitboxes from the attack.
QCF+Y+Z does way less damage, for lesser range than QCF+X+Y, and is still safe on block
"Fingerf**k" F, B, F, B, A+b drags opponents backwards on block.
Can't seem to block "Angry Gajardo", which is a fullscreen attack that seemingly is UNBLOCKABLE and deals 776 DAMAGE, even for a Level 4, this is a ridiculous cheap way to rig matches with no risks involved whatsoever, furthermore, in the attack, he seems to be IMPERVIOUS to most attack types, and given how long the P2 is paused through the move, using it almost guarantees a hit. I think it's related to that precisely, he seems to be attacking during a Pause, as in the coding the move is stated to be blocked, also,. The attacks he's impervious to all Projectiles, and Normal and Special attacks, except for throws.

I'd list more, but I had enough.

Links to this post

Carlos the Stickman by Josh Geary (Read 2048 times)

Daniel9999999

Carlos the Stickman by Josh Geary

タイタニックリバース

Re: Gajardo the Stickman v1.1 by Josh Geary

shotgun160

Re: Gajardo the Stickman v1.1 by Josh Geary

a487561

Re: Gajardo the Stickman v1.1 by Josh Geary

Daniel9999999

Re: Gajardo the Stickman v1.1 by Josh Geary

タイタニックリバース

Re: Carlos the Stickman by Josh Geary