YesNoOk
avatar

Good Mecha anime (Read 23536 times)

Started by Duo Solo, June 20, 2013, 07:57:01 pm
Share this topic:
Re: Good Mecha anime
#21  June 20, 2013, 11:32:51 pm
  • ******
  • ゴゴゴゴゴ
Battle Angel Alita is the bees knees, I strongly suggest you watch it.  :yes:
Terrible anime adaptation from an amazing manga. Also, it's only what? Two episodes?
Basquash
Ginga Kikoutai Majestic Prince
Muvluv
These are fucking terrible too, and Majestic Prince is still airing and not even halfway done.
Geass and Kannazuki no Miko (You know, trying to be edgy adding the twist of a dumb lesbian NTRing the main character with zero to none mecha action? Really) are horrible too.

The rest of the suggestions in this thread are alright (Gunbuster is really really good. Avoid Diebuster though)
Gundam? 08th MS Team (And heck, all the UC OVAS, 0080, 0083, Unicorn...), the Original Gundam movie trilogy and G-Gundam are pretty good (And if you enjoy them you can move on to Z, ZZ and Victory). Gundam 00 is enjoyable.

Shin Mazinger, Getter Robo Armageddon, Kikaider and Super Robot Taisen OG: The Inspector are pretty enjoyable too.
Some of these suggestions are terrible, I only really see a few actually worth watching.
I fucking know, right?
Shin Getter
G Gundam
Giant Robo
GaoGaiGar
MAH AFROAMERICAN.
Re: Good Mecha anime
#22  June 20, 2013, 11:47:01 pm
  • ******
  • Professional Procrastinator
    • USA
    • http://moon-girard.tumblr.com/
Anyone say Gun X Sword if not then Gun X Sword.

Genesis of Aquarion pretty decent as well.

Re: Good Mecha anime
#23  June 20, 2013, 11:59:15 pm
  • ******
  • [E]
    • Mexico
snip

because generic stuff that does nothing interesting with the genre is better right ?

The ones that shindio suggested are good examples of the genre, it's good to watch a few of those.
Last Edit: June 21, 2013, 12:09:07 am by maximilianjenus
Re: Good Mecha anime
#24  June 21, 2013, 12:17:00 am
  • ******
  • ゴゴゴゴゴ
Anyone say Gun X Sword if not then Gun X Sword.

Genesis of Aquarion pretty decent as well.
These pretty good too.
The El Dorado V episode was amazing.
because generic stuff that does nothing interesting with the genre is better right ?
I fail to see how Shin Mazinger is generic with the ending it pulled, 08th MS team isn't a generic Gundam series at all, it has the most mature (And military trained) main character conducting guerrilla warfare instead of your generic teenager hijacking a Gundam (And how is G-Gundam a generic Gundam?!), I could go on and on. Just because you know little to nothing about said anime (Or genre, one or two franchises aside) doesn't make it generic (Or you know, because it was the first one to set a trope/concept or was the precursor or something that was reused later on)

but yeah, the ones that shindioh suggested are good examples of the genre that do nothing interesting, but it's still good to watch a few of those.
Nice (but weak) jab.

Shit like Geass and Kannazuki no Miko could be considered entertaining for different (And wrong) reasons, but "good" (As the thread's subject implies)?
Yeah uh... no. The only people who truly like those series like them for everything (You know, retarded "In your face" fanservice or  being entertained watching a trainwreck of a story with dumb plot twists to see where it ends up) but the mecha.

Now if the subject is "entertaining" mecha anime, then add garbage like Valvrave. And by all means, he should watch "Fucking dumb lesbian raping the main character with a flute - The animation" too. You know, those are not good but they're "entertaining"
Re: Good Mecha anime
#25  June 21, 2013, 12:22:15 am
  • ****
  • Working on MGS2's VR missions.
    • USA
It's good until the last episode.

Don't watch Evangelion for a long while, period. If you are really that curious, only watch the Rebuild films.
They're less confusing.

rebuild is more confusing
Then he doesn't have to watch 3.33.

First two films aren't as hard to understand.(Unless you're talking about the last half of 2.0, which is confusing.)

Plus, the original series has some higlights that rebuild doesn't, berserk Eva-01, many of the angels are better than in rebuild, etc..
But I'm sure he'd rather see a more confident Shinji.(I know what happens in Rebuild of Evangelion 3.33, but I won't spoil it.)

Working on personal projects and spending less (non anime watching) time on internet.

You're just going to have to PM me if I get chosen
for the question thread.
Re: Good Mecha anime
#26  June 21, 2013, 12:26:26 am
  • ******
  • [E]
    • Mexico
snip

no big deal, it was not supossed to be a jab, that is why I toned it down after i noticed it looked like one.

I would rather have you go on and explain what makes muvluv a horrible mecha series and what makes a good mecha series, especially for the ones you suggested, since (as I have said it before) I am not big on mecha or toku and only watch stuff that sounds interesting or has been recomended so I pretty much have to recomend stuff based on what I have already watched/been told (I have nothing against he genre either).

anime is already niche enough and thanks to the recent geek explosion in the western countries (big bang theory, lor dof the rings) it's not even the geeky elitist thing it used to be before, so fighting about genres is pretty pointless.

     Posted: June 21, 2013, 12:39:23 am
i went the same way I recomend slice of life to people who asks me about it, like tellnig them to watch azumanga/ cromartie as the are safe, then depending on what I know about them tell them about stuff that they might like ( someone who is into gfx design/visual arts will enjoy hidamari and GA, someone who is into lesbians will liek yuru yuri or kanamemo, peoepl who like physical jokes will like kill me baby , etc...)

I mean, we are not a bunch of homofaggots, like those in the wrestling topic.
Re: Good Mecha anime
#27  June 21, 2013, 01:08:22 am
  • ******
  • always unique totally interesting sometimes myster
I like Genocyber because of the blood.
conscious dreamers can be treasurer to their own currency
im a conscious dreamer
therefore i can be treasurer to my own currency

i can be the mind controller
Re: Good Mecha anime
#28  June 21, 2013, 01:14:47 am
  • ******
  • Does this looks like the face of mercy?
hey when you say mecha anime does it need to be about giant robots? otherwise i would reccomend tekkaman blade

or if you need giant robot action then there's epsiode 35 of smile precure where cure happy transforms in a giant robot taiyo no shisha tetsujin 28-go/new gigantor/ironman 28 aka the 80's tetsujin anime; no beam spamming, revolutionary battle systems, superior race, emo pilots or any of that bullshit, no! it's jut a kid and his robot kicking giant alien robot ass using nothing but their wits and melee attacks. FUCK YEAH! (the downside: you can only find RAWS for the complete series or dubbed and incomplete)

and another vote for g-gundam

also, i enjoyed code geass for many reasons but the macha aspect of the show was definetly not one of them. i can reccomend it to people but definelty not as a mecha show, anyone who liked the mecha aspect of code geass either has shit taste or is under the effect of a geass that causes shit taste
Re: Good Mecha anime
#29  June 21, 2013, 01:19:27 am
  • *****
  • JoJo is boring
    • USA
Re: Good Mecha anime
#30  June 21, 2013, 01:23:02 am
  • ******
  • Space Dandy wa uchuu wa Dandy de-aru
    • Chile
    • Skype - basara.kubikiri
    • network.mugenguild.com/basara/
Here're some few nobody mentioned yet:
-Magic Knight Rayearth
-Brigadoon
-Martian Sucessor Nadesico
-Macross and Gundam series... except Macross Frontier and Gundam Seed, those are soap opera with mechas
-Not an anime, but still... Megas XLR :P
Re: Good Mecha anime
#31  June 21, 2013, 01:26:22 am
  • ******
  • Does this looks like the face of mercy?
-Magic Knight Rayearth
now i still haven't seen this one but correct me if i'm wrong... isn't that a magical girl show?

also, SDF macross is the onyl series i would reccoemend form the franchise as a mecha show
Re: Good Mecha anime
#32  June 21, 2013, 01:31:14 am
  • ****
  • Mother Fucking Money!
    • www.mugenfreeforall.com
IMO

I enjoyed the full metal panic series (fumoffu was a spinoff)

gurren lagann was good but not as amazing as ppl make it to be.

Im gonna get killed for this but... Medabots imo was a decent anime I used to watch when I was a kid

there might be some more but thats off the top of my head.
You'll fix chuchoryu ? Sounds like a plan. How about you code him from scratch instead ?
Star Fucker said:
Do you often run naked in the streets screaming "YOU STUPID ASS FAGGOT NIGGA BITCHES WHY YOU NO HELP ME WITH MY MATH HOMEWORK !!!!???!!!!"
Re: Good Mecha anime
#33  June 21, 2013, 01:32:23 am
  • ******
  • [E]
    • Mexico
-Magic Knight Rayearth
now i still haven't seen this one but correct me if i'm wrong... isn't that a magical girl show?

also, SDF macross is the onyl series i would reccoemend form the franchise as a mecha show

yep, it's a mahou shoujo show with mechas, the plot twist is pretty nice though I tend to recomend it as baby's first shoujo series ( it's either that or yamanade depending whether the person likes comedies or action).

anyway, in your opinion what makes a mecha series a good mecha series ?
Re: Good Mecha anime
#34  June 21, 2013, 01:32:45 am
  • ******
  • Q.E.D.
    • USA
    • network.mugenguild.com/jmorphman

  • Online
Spoiler: MECHA ANIME 101 (click to see content)

Spoiler: INTERMEDIATE MECHA ANIME (click to see content)

Spoiler: ADVANCED MECHA ANIME (click to see content)

Spoiler: SENIOR PROJECT: GUNDAM FUN WITH PROFESSOR JMORPHMAN (click to see content)
Oh, I've wasted my life.
Last Edit: August 02, 2013, 07:01:56 am by Jmorphman
Re: Good Mecha anime
#35  June 21, 2013, 01:47:06 am
  • avatar
  • ******
    • USA
I've been waiting for you Jmorphman. And you didn't disappoint.

EDIT:
I'll start with Mecha Anime 101. Whoa.

2nd EDIT:
Did you really watch all those Gundams? :fear:

Last Edit: June 21, 2013, 01:54:49 am by Duo Solo
Re: Good Mecha anime
#36  June 21, 2013, 01:49:13 am
  • *****
  • haven't got a clue
    • USA
    • Skype - hector.roman98
Eva will always be one of those series people will be split on, and it really isn't as important as it used to be in all honesty.

Also I'm gonna be "that guy" and recommend MD Geist because it's more satisfying than Eva.
Last Edit: June 21, 2013, 02:01:38 am by Roman55
Re: Good Mecha anime
#37  June 21, 2013, 01:58:53 am
  • ******
  • ゴゴゴゴゴ
-I approve of Jmorph's post (Then again, I might be the only one here who has watched all the Gundam serie- Scratch that, I haven't watched Superior Defender, maybe I'll watch it someday just for completion's sake).
Honestly, I think you need to know some basics about C.E. before watching Stargazer. And SEED is alright, not good or terribly bad. DEED Destiny is the biggest offender. AGE has some salvageable stuff, but for the most part is plain bad.
Also, Votoms is a big franchise, sure it's no Gundam but... personally I'd start with Mellowlink.

-Rayearth has almost no mecha/genie action, but as a standalone series is pretty good.

-Nadesico is OK as long as you avoid the movie.

Because calling something terrible will explain why it is terrible
If you really need me to explain why garbage like Basquash is terrible. Well...
shit taste or is under the effect of a geass that causes shit taste
But well, if you insist, it's been yet another failed entry in Kawamori's latest failed attempts at straying from Macross and it shows that if he's not working on Macross he ends up directing fanservice-ridden trainwrecks, the CG was terrible, the story was dumb. And in the second haf The idols ruined the show's pacing (He tried to make it like Macross again to regain viewers and it just ended up ruining the show even more).
But hey, if you like this http://www.kid9.net/blog/images/Basquash!%20-%2007%20-%20Large%2038.jpg and this http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_mat69jbXcp1ronge7o1_500.gif by all means watch it ::)


Muvluv's the first 2 episodes make it look like the series is going to go into an entirely different direction than it actually went. Then again it's based on a VN and light novel.  So it's a story about love (read, harem) and girls in really dumb-looking sexy uniforms, the war and mecha action is just really a backdrop (And it's really noticeable when they force the beach episode almost out of nowhere), the characters aren't likable... they're not bad either, they're just bland. And the main character is the worst offender, they spend so much time explaining how the BETA are this huge threat to humanity but he ends up having a ridiculous amount of plot armor (Although to be fair, he doesn't act like your generic dumb as hell harem lead)

Animation and art quality is all over the place, as expected of something by Satelight (Oh HI Basquash!). It was also directed by Inagaki Takayuki who LOVES fanservice and ignores plot (He directed Rosario + Vampire after all); and again it's really easy to realize this after the first two episodes are full of plot and nothing really happens for the rest of the series (I'm pretty sure that the VN and light novels are more consistent and this is one of the main issues the anime had, terrible studio and terrible director)
Re: Good Mecha anime
#38  June 21, 2013, 02:52:49 am
  • *****
  • JoJo is boring
    • USA
Thank you
Re: Good Mecha anime
#39  June 21, 2013, 03:19:46 am
  • ****
  • No meaning to me, just an empty box.
That JM post reminded me that I wanted to check out Votoms for a while after getting a look at Armour Hunter Mellowlink. I guess I should get on that soon.

Also is Macross Plus a no go or what? I guess it doesn't matter now since I'm getting any way but I'll still ask since the mecha experts are here.
Re: Good Mecha anime
#40  June 21, 2013, 03:23:09 am
  • ****
  • All my machines are made for destruction.
    • USA
GunXSword is fucking great and has one of the most satisfying endings I've ever seen in all the anime I've watched. I think it and Gurren Lagann tie for my favorite modern mecha anime.

Turn A is a masterpiece, but I agree that you gotta get some other Gundams in before watching it.

I like Betterman, and I don't think anyone's mentioned it. So Betterman. It shares continuity with GaoGaiGar, but it's definitely not similar in tone.
If you close your eyes, your life a naked truth revealed
Dreams you never lived and scars never healed
In the darkness light will take you to the other side
And find me waiting there, you'll see if you just close your eyes.
If you just close your eyes.
If you just close your eyes.