YesNoOk
avatar

Mugen Guild Reopened Database Feedback Thread (upd. 30/12/2016 + B-kun is out) (Read 764700 times)

Started by Nunor, October 12, 2011, 01:27:39 am
Share this topic:
Mugen Guild Reopened Database Feedback Thread (upd. 30/12/2016 + B-kun is out)
#1  October 12, 2011, 01:27:39 am
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
As suggested this will be the thread for giving general feedback about the revamped Mugen Guild Site
and for posting corrections, additions etc...

Be in mind that not all sections are complete yet, so only complete sections are visible in the site for now.
So for those sections in the site fire away and help to make it better.

Next section released will be Street Fighter series in a few days...

http://mugenguild.atspace.eu/start.html
http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html

Site Section Template for newbies  ;D


I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Last Edit: December 30, 2016, 03:42:10 am by Basara Beat
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#2  October 12, 2011, 02:44:26 am
  • ****
  • Maker of obscurity.
    • http://tetsuwanatom.b1.jcink.com/
I did once a question about the forum being restored or not and I got really happy to know the site was revived with your return.
I'd like to see the character preview with a animated gif and screenshots like before.
Also, any plans to add Magical Chaser in the site database?
I released several characters and stages from the game.
-Toshio Tenma
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#3  October 12, 2011, 11:29:28 pm
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Character preview and animated gif in the way it was before will not be possible again.
I've thinking in an alternative way to get a char preview yet...

As for magical chaser, probably yes but not until all major sections are complete.
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.

GLB

Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#4  October 12, 2011, 11:44:12 pm
  • *****
    • network.mugenguild.com/glb/
I was just wondering, is there going to be links to anything else on that certain game?

Stages?  Lifebars? Screenpacks? Etc.

Or is it only characters?
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#5  October 13, 2011, 01:21:24 am
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Yes, will be added later on or has i go finding them. It will only be a priority after finishing all major characters sections.
The MOTW section already has some stages links. It was kind a test...
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.

GLB

Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#6  October 13, 2011, 01:23:36 am
  • *****
    • network.mugenguild.com/glb/
Oh, sorry I must've missed that.

Well, this is a great idea then.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#7  October 13, 2011, 01:36:22 am
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Still, unlike chars, others sections(stages, screenpacks, etc...) will only have online links.
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#8  October 13, 2011, 02:31:38 am
  • ******
  • Loyal to the Game
  • I'M SHADYYYYYYYYYY
    • USA
    • www.trinitymugen.net
No King of Fighters section? :gonk:


Course I could understand that one being incomplete...
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#9  October 14, 2011, 01:12:49 am
  • ******
  • Back on the track
  • Let's kick some asses
    • Chile
    • network.mugenguild.com/basara/
Good to see a specific thread in MUGEN Discussion ;) and I autoquote this since maybe you don't read this in the other thread :P
Some stuff about Hungry Wolf section:
*Fatal Fury:
-Ixnaydk made a custom version for FF1 Terry Bogard (avaliable in PaoDeMugen)
-Blue Mary oficially appeared in Fatal Fury 3, so since you merged that game in RB section, she shouldn't be there, same for Franco Bash
-In Geese Howard, appeared Masa twice
-Falchion22 made Andy Bogard and Mai Shiranui from FFS
-Star Platinum made Terry Bogard from FF3, not from FF1/2/S
*Real Bout:
-O Ilusionista made 2 versions of Bob Wilson, one of them is custom and with a lot of FX called "Bob Wilson EX"
-Alfred first was made with KOF by MugenChina guys (probably Misamu), then Vans used those sprites to make his own version
-Hiram Yagami made a custom version of RB2 Mai Shiranui
-Ironmugen (David Demianoff) made Jin Chonshu from FF3 and RB1, Terry Bogard from RBS, Geese Howard from RBS and the edited characters Eddy Stanley (edited from Kim) and Laurent Demianoff (edited from Yamazaki)
-Cannon Musume's Geese has custom gameplay, should be in special section
-Star Platinum made Franco Bash from RB2, Billy Kane from RB2 and Terry Bogard from FF3. Also, found his old web hosted in Web Archive and all downloads worked ;)
-Pneophen made Duck King from RBS
-Bad Darkness made Tung Fu Rue from RBS
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#10  October 14, 2011, 02:33:46 am
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Was copying the quote now  :) Guess it's not necessary now  :P

All your corrections are made(not online yet), except Terry Bogard by Ixnaydk which is a incomplete version and
with no sound so i will not add it (mainly because the lack of sound).

I'm finishing the Street Figther Sections and have some doubts about some chars :

Master Sean by LaQuak
Slightly Pissed Off Ryu by Rikard
Kasumi Todo by amanojaku
Evil Ryu by Vyn
Akuma by blackchaos07
Chaos Blanka by blackchaos07

Need help classifying this ones...
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Last Edit: October 14, 2011, 03:13:26 am by Nunor
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#11  October 14, 2011, 02:38:09 am
  • avatar
  • ****
Evil Ryu by Vyn, Master Sean by LaQuak and Slightly Pissed Off Ryu by Rikard should be placed in Street Fighter Special Version. I am not sure about the other three which I did not play with them before

GOH

Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#12  October 14, 2011, 11:48:18 am
  • ******
  • DEATH AWAITS YOU
    • Portugal
blackchaos a.k.a. BC's characters are characters with customized SFA gameplay I think. I'm not sure about his Chaos Blanka though.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#13  October 14, 2011, 07:25:19 pm
  • ******
  • Back on the track
  • Let's kick some asses
    • Chile
    • network.mugenguild.com/basara/
All your corrections are made(not online yet), except Terry Bogard by Ixnaydk which is a incomplete version and
with no sound so i will not add it (mainly because the lack of sound).
No problem, in fact Ixnaydk left that char incomplete and stated it as open source

About your doubts for those chars:
-Kasumi is a AOF3 edited version, so it should be in AOF special versions
-All LaQuak's Masters are edits so they should be in special versions, same for BlackChaos/BC's SF chars
-Vyn made 2 Evil Ryu, both of them should be in special versions, one from SF3 and another one from SFA/MVC
-SPO Ryu by Rikard is a joke character, so it should be in special versions
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#14  October 14, 2011, 11:41:10 pm
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Evil Ryu by Vyn, Master Sean by LaQuak and Slightly Pissed Off Ryu by Rikard should be placed in Street Fighter Special Version. I am not sure about the other three which I did not play with them before

SF 3 section right ?
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#15  October 15, 2011, 01:39:14 am
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Another update is now online :

- Street Fighter and Capcom Fighter Evolution sections added
- Led System deployed but not functional yet
- Sections updates
- Stages, Screenpack and Lifebars sections initiated in some sections
- Added game sections fighter animations (sprite categorization)

Hope there is not too many mistakes  --; There are some SF chars missing but i'll be adding them in next updates.
Please report them any anyway.

http://mugenguild.atspace.eu/start.html



I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#16  October 15, 2011, 05:42:16 am
  • avatar
  • ****
Some mistakes in Street Fighter Section:
SF2 Section:
- Typo: Evil Ryun :Guille_N_Roll(SSF2)
- I don't remember Fido made SF2 characters

SFA Section:
- Cammy by Pots should not be there
- Blanka and Cody by Gou-San plays like in MvC version, should be placed in Special Version
- Dhalsim by NRF should be placed in Special version
- H' also made a SFA3's Honda
- Maki and Eagle are missing if you want to include PSP's SFA3Max characters since I saw Ingrid and Yun there
- M.Bison (if you are referring to dictator) is not created by Descolor
- I am not sure for some special characters like Mech Zangief, Dark Sakura and Mech Gouki, should they be placed in Marvel Section because they only appear in Marvel vs Street Fighter

SF3 Section:
- Alex by Most_Mysterious & The_None should be placed in Special Version
- Dudley, Yang and Sean by Buckus should place in Special Version (CvS Style)
- All Umihei's characters are here: http://3rd.geocities.jp/mugen_umihei/
- Ryu and Sean by DG should be placed in Special Version (MvC Style)
- Umihei also made a Yun

SF4 Section:
- Werewood have not released his Oni yet

Fido made most Street Fighter characters to play his  own style, I think should be placed under special version

Capcom Fighting Evolution Section:
- I think you need to remove many links there because most characters link you linked them are not in Capcom Fighting Jam but just SFA3, SF3, Darkstalker and so on
- Ingrid by Shiroto should be placed in Special version, Melty Blood Gameplay
- You should retain: Jedah by Izumo and Zangief by Koopakoot
Last Edit: October 15, 2011, 11:38:56 am by devilgenemugen
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#17  October 15, 2011, 04:22:49 pm
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
Some mistakes in Street Fighter Section:
SF2 Section:
- Typo: Evil Ryun :Guille_N_Roll(SSF2)
- I don't remember Fido made SF2 characters

Corrected typo.
Fido did make some SF2 characters. They are available in the Street Fighter section of Mugenchina.

SFA Section:
- Cammy by Pots should not be there
- Blanka and Cody by Gou-San plays like in MvC version, should be placed in Special Version
- Dhalsim by NRF should be placed in Special version
- H' also made a SFA3's Honda
- Maki and Eagle are missing if you want to include PSP's SFA3Max characters since I saw Ingrid and Yun there
- M.Bison (if you are referring to dictator) is not created by Descolor
- I am not sure for some special characters like Mech Zangief, Dark Sakura and Mech Gouki, should they be placed in Marvel Section because they only appear in Marvel vs Street Fighter

- Moved Cammy by Pots to SFA Special version. Correct ?
- M. Bison by Descolor is actually Balrog. Corrected. (Do you know why they did change this names in Japan ? It's a confusion...)
- The Marvel section is for Marvel characters only. Mech Zangief, Dark Sakura and Mech Gouki will be in the coming vs section too.
- I was not sure about PSP SFA chars, but since Ingrid and Yun were converted will add Maki and Eagle too.
- Corrected all others to special section too.


SF3 Section:
- Alex by Most_Mysterious & The_None should be placed in Special Version
- Dudley, Yang and Sean by Buckus should place in Special Version (CvS Style)
- All Umihei's characters are here: http://3rd.geocities.jp/mugen_umihei/
- Ryu and Sean by DG should be placed in Special Version (MvC Style)
- Umihei also made a Yun

All done.

SF4 Section:
- Werewood have not released his Oni yet

There is a Omni on his site to download. Is It not Oni from SF4 ?

Fido made most Street Fighter characters to play his  own style, I think should be placed under special version
:ninja: (maybe will open an exception to this one...)

Capcom Fighting Evolution Section:
- I think you need to remove many links there because most characters link you linked them are not in Capcom Fighting Jam but just SFA3, SF3, Darkstalker and so on
- Ingrid by Shiroto should be placed in Special version, Melty Blood Gameplay
- You should retain: Jedah by Izumo and Zangief by Koopakoot

I tought characters in this game were taken from other games, but did not have much differences from the original games
they come from (except gameplay maybe)

I remember that some Red Earth were ripped from this game tough (it's in the readme file)
So only Ingrid, Jedah and Zangief should really stay here in your opinion ?

Corrections are not yet online (later today).
I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#18  October 15, 2011, 04:58:03 pm
  • avatar
  • ****
- Moved Cammy by Pots to SFA Special version. Correct ?
- M. Bison by Descolor is actually Balrog. Corrected. (Do you know why they did change this names in Japan ? It's a confusion...)
- I think Cammy should move to Capcom vs SNK section since Pots's version plays more like from Capcom vs SNK
- I am not sure, but I like to call the Boxer(M.Bison), Claw(Balrog), Dictator(Vega), Akuma(Gouki)

There is a Omni on his site to download. Is It not Oni from SF4 ?
Yeah, it is not Oni from SF4, it is an edited character called Omni, you can put him in Special Version


I tought characters in this game were taken from other games, but did not have much differences from the original games
they come from (except gameplay maybe)
I remember that some Red Earth were ripped from this game tough (it's in the readme file)
So only Ingrid, Jedah and Zangief should really stay here in your opinion ?
Corrections are not yet online (later today).
Well, just the hit spark and some game play are different but I am not too sure too, this section is rather confusing, maybe we should wait for someone else here to see what are their opinion but Jedah by Izumo, Zangief by Koopakoot and Ingrid by Shiroto/Warusaki3 should stay there and also Jedah by BBH in Trinity Mugen should also be in Capcom Fighting Jam Section
Last Edit: October 15, 2011, 05:06:43 pm by devilgenemugen
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#19  October 15, 2011, 09:53:05 pm
  • ****
  • Mugen Fighters Guild Reopens...
    • Portugal
    • http://network.mugenguild.com/guild/start.html
I am not sure, but I like to call the Boxer(M.Bison), Claw(Balrog), Dictator(Vega), Akuma(Gouki)

Here we know them as
Dictator(M.Bison), Boxer(Balrog), Claw(Vega), Gouki(Akuma)  ;D

Power Instinct Section is now online and Power Instinct Matrimelee Sections was updated.

Also i've split Samurai Shodow section, but it's still duplicated until it's complete.
I need help classifing the remaining fighters in the Samurai Shodown I section that should not be there.

If anyone could help it would be apreciated.

I believe it's your fate to be here. It's your destiny.
Last Edit: October 15, 2011, 09:56:11 pm by Nunor
Re: Mugen Guild Site Feedback Thread
#20  October 16, 2011, 03:43:11 am
  • avatar
  • ****
In Samurai Shodown 1 Section there are typos:
- Haohmaru by K3shin and Super Scott are Samurai Shodown 3 and above
- Nakoruru by Ali, Ukyo by Intense_Mc and Jubei by Kgenjuro as well
I would say Samurai Shodown 1 and Samurai Shodown 2 are quite similar, maybe you should move Samurai Shodown 2 character to Samurai Shodown 1 Section.
Here are a few duplicate links I found and needed to move to Samurai Shodown 1 and 2 Section:
- Amakusa Tokisada : Lord Sinistro(SS)
-  Earthquake : Ayce, Fujy
- Gen-an Shiranui : Kojya(SS2), Gen_an, Basara-Kun, Kusare-Miyabi
- Hattori Hanzou : Star Platinum(SS2)
- Kuroko : P(ushing), Laiso_7, Gonzo
- Kyoshiro Senryo : NRF
- Neinhalt Sieger : K3nShiN, 3ha
- Nicotine Caffeine : KGenjuro, Yaten
- Rashoujin Mizuki : R Marker
- Tam Tam: Lord Sinistro(SS)
- Wan-Fu : MugenMage(SS), NRF
- Yagyu Jubei : NRF

In Power Instinct Section:
- Chinnen by Ihoo1836's link is here: http://blog.naver.com/ihoo1836