The Mugen Fighters Guild - Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Markpachi

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#21 December 07, 2013, 04:00:00 pm

LET THE SWAGGING COMMENCE

Nah, let him do what he wants. He did say it's his "tactics". If he doesn't want feedback to be posted at his release thread, then who are we to stop him.

Good luck with you project.

~Hale "R@CE" Caesar~

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#22 December 07, 2013, 04:18:58 pm

This big boy spitting out 250 rounds a minute!!!

NoZ said, December 07, 2013, 03:21:15 pm

I really think you should finish at least one of these characters,cause they all feel so incomplete and to keep on releasing stuff like this is only hurting you and whatever reputation youre trying to have,how can you try have a fullgame when you cant finish at least one of this characters,you cant build a house without a solid foundation,the sooner you realize this,your work will be better and prob people would start to take you and your work more seriously,listen to some of this guys here,they know the game and its rules,some feedback may piss you off,nobody likes it when people talk about your stuff in a negative way,but you learn from it,adapt to it and become better,best of luck

Agreed!

Markpachi said, December 07, 2013, 04:00:00 pm

Nah, let him do what he wants. He did say it's his "tactics". If he doesn't want feedback to be posted at his release thread, then who are we to stop him.

Good luck with you project.

No one is trying to stop him, but if someone posts their releases in a thread, feedback will be given whether they like it or not. And no one can stop anyone from doing that because it's our right to give feedback if we want to once it has been posted in a forum.

You could tell people not to post feedback 1000 times but i bet out of that 1000, atleast 1 person is still going to do it anyway.

But he willingly wants to improve his creations. He even said himself, he wants to improve because he has a desire to. Not because anyone told him to so.

I wish him good luck with his project too, and no one is perfect when it comes to making mugen characters, but I hope he can learn from his mistakes and make the neccessary decisions to improve the quality of his work before he decides to release something again

Last Edit: December 07, 2013, 05:35:44 pm by ~R@CE AKIR@~

Saikoro

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#23 December 07, 2013, 04:42:32 pm

Portrait Prodigy EX+

Since feedback is not allowed, I'll leave it at these two emotes as they best describe my thoughts.

I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Carry on.

All of your Mugen Portrait needs may be found HERE.

Unstabler said, January 31, 2013, 04:11:33 pm

I'd like to report two robots on the MFG forums: One is EXShadow. The other is Saikoro.

GarchompMatt said, September 17, 2013, 12:37:33 am

There should be a Saikoro plugin for Photoshop.

HUNGRY WOLF

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#24 December 07, 2013, 05:18:26 pm

Do do do do do do do dodo dododo dodo

If you are willing to the route that R@ce said why not open a wip thread on the character you are currently working on I'm sure ppl would be happy to help and instead of posting betas all the time show screen shots or videos of your progress so ppl can give you feed back . Then when all is complete (basic, special, and super) post that you need beta testers. I'm sure ppl will help to improve your work.

Good luck with your project.

[DKG]

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#25 December 08, 2013, 10:17:40 am

Hey look! It's Dat Kof Guy!

I see the screenpack still uses those low res images. it really hurts the look of it. Also those select portraits...

Basara Dandy

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#26 December 10, 2013, 01:54:17 pm

Space Dandy wa uchuu wa Dandy de-aru

I got just a doubt about this: if you don't want feedback for your "fullgame", why did you leave this thread open to posts?? Do you want congratulations and "nice car +1" posts as in MMV or forums like that?? If you release something, the less you can expect is feedback, you can't only receive good or bad comments, you know, it's the intenet man. If you don't want this, I suggest to lock this thread instead to keep it open as it now

Normal WIPS - CF63 1/3 - Ideas - Anti-Gouki Project

Romeotantan

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#27 December 10, 2013, 03:07:36 pm

Portrait maker/AI coder

I think he needs to know the difference between feedback and insults, if some one is giving you feedback it means that they like your chars but have a deeper knowledge of the source game than you do, so they like your work so much they want it to be perfect, but if some one comes telling you that you create shit or your chars suck just for the sake of insulting you, rest assured that every body here will defend you.

Accepting construcive feedback is mature, even the greatest mugen creators accept feedback, we are humans and humans make mistakes all the time, but the real mistake is not learning from them and keep doing the same over and over again.

http://romeotantan.webs.com/
My AI coding tutorial: http://mugenguild.com/forumx/index.php?topic=108420.0

Jmorphman

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#28 December 10, 2013, 08:35:00 pm

Q.E.D.
Online

Oh boy.

OK, guys, calm the fuck down. If an author doesn't want feedback then don't try to bully them into accepting it, because even if you do, it's already pretty clear that they don't want your feedback. Why waste your time, then? Don't act like this. You guys should know better.

To CvS Artist: if you don't want people giving you feedback, that's fine. You don't have to take feedback. But the only way you can guarantee that people won't post feedback in your threads is to lock it. You can't demand people not leave feedback and leave the thread open, because one of the purposes of having these threads is to get feedback. You don't have to follow any feedback in these threads, but if you leave the thread unlocked people are probably gonna post some, regardless of if you want them to. It's up to you to decide what you want here.

abls1

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#29 December 11, 2013, 01:16:49 pm

I understand how he feels because feedback some times seem like you are creating their character not what you intended to do!

New MUGEN Forum Opened

JackTheAwkward

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#30 January 13, 2014, 05:57:40 am

SEAN MATSUUDA!!!!

Dude, I can totally help with Maxi. A bit.
If your putting him in the game, it is Soul Edge.

Spoiler, click to toggle visibilty

Last Edit: January 13, 2014, 06:05:03 am by CaptMUGEN

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#31 January 13, 2014, 10:06:43 am

Thx for this demo...but i think i'll pass... You've got some good intentions by releasing an unfinished work...but for me it is not enough...even for a demo and i'm not looking forward to play this Mugen game...cause nothing keeps me waiting for it.

Your Screenpack looks awful and too blurry....of course it' an old fashion way, but i'd prefer to see your final product...cause for now it is a little bit, how can i say that without being rude or hurt you...shitty.

Your characters are the same way, they are looking awful, all are Low-res...but in such a bad low-res that i can't imagine putting them in an other SP.

When you release a demo, you need to think that many people like me, are soul calibur or soul edge fans and we are looking for some good chars...even if your SP sucks, we wants good coded characters and most of that playable ones.

A demo for me is a well done SP, and 2 Hi-res and well coded characters, that will lead me impatiently to the download link.

as a conclusion, all your work need to be redone and all characters need to be improves, the way they look the moves they use etc...

You probably have the skills to do what we are expecting from you, don't be so quick to release things, take the time, be patient, first try to make one good SP, and then one good char, then sit, try your work, and try to tell you if it is good to be released this way, if not, change it...peace and take the time.

Nobody will steal your idea. i recommand you to visit deviant art site and get in touch with some good characters designer or spriters, let them design one or two chars, and then code them. try to use mugen 1.0, or 1.1 for some best looking SP...and then you'll be able to release a good demo...and everyone will fall for it... For sure i will be the first.

With time, efforts and hope, you'll managed to get very good feedbacks from the community.

Do your best, now i will look forward to your project, and hope you'll take all advantages of what has been told to you. I'm, and we are not bad guys, but simply mugen players that are waiting with great interest, to your game.

Good luck, Do your best...and C U maybe a little bit later.

FeLo_Llop

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#32 January 13, 2014, 10:50:02 am

Kiss me, I'm famous!!
Online

^ Such a stupid post. Not meaning that you are stupid, but those words are, because:
- This is a HOBBY. No one forces you to follow this.
- It's a DEMO. It's something to be released with necessary(in some aspects) flaws for making it better in the future.
- Sprites in Low Res: This is FREE. What the HELL did you expect? HR with HR filters? Or maybe HD? Spriting is, if you didn't know, HARD, even in a low res work.
- If you're that superfan, then, WHY NOT SPRITING THEM YOURSELF? As you're that superfan, you would be making something HR(or maybe HD!!) for us to download...But it's easier to "insult" the guy who AT LEAST IS MAKING SOMETHING.
- That "I expect from you" tone. Man, you're not his boss. You're not his dad. You're nothing to him. You're just someone who saw "soul edge mugen" maybe in google or when the message popped up here and you expectd to have something PROFESSIONAL without throwing some bucks to it.
- Deviantart. Yeah, sure. There's a lot of spriters who makes a WHOLE character if you tell them so. Of course.

I may not be liking the guy's work(because I don't like it, even I love SE/ SC), but I'm not coming here to say "your work is X", or "you suck". He said (in the first post?) that he doesn't wants feedback which, in my humble opinion is THE WORST you can do for a project you're working at. But, hey! I respect his decission not blaming the guy. So, your reply to this topic is...empty. Some people said things(yeah!) but at least they're not using THAT tone of you.

Human

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#33 January 13, 2014, 11:09:00 am

- Might get annyoing from time to time.

This is beta not demo.

Demo is a demonstration version of a full game, for example we take 1 level of CoD, use 4-5 weapons and you can finish it in 20 minutes.

Fighting game demo is a version of a full game with few (4 out of 20) FULLY COMPLETED characters, what you have gave us is a beta.

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#34 January 13, 2014, 12:24:42 pm

FeLo_Llop said, January 13, 2014, 10:50:02 am

^ Such a stupid post. Not meaning that you are stupid, but those words are, because:
- This is a HOBBY. No one forces you to follow this.
- It's a DEMO. It's something to be released with necessary(in some aspects) flaws for making it better in the future.
- Sprites in Low Res: This is FREE. What the HELL did you expect? HR with HR filters? Or maybe HD? Spriting is, if you didn't know, HARD, even in a low res work.
- If you're that superfan, then, WHY NOT SPRITING THEM YOURSELF? As you're that superfan, you would be making something HR(or maybe HD!!) for us to download...But it's easier to "insult" the guy who AT LEAST IS MAKING SOMETHING.
- That "I expect from you" tone. Man, you're not his boss. You're not his dad. You're nothing to him. You're just someone who saw "soul edge mugen" maybe in google or when the message popped up here and you expectd to have something PROFESSIONAL without throwing some bucks to it.
- Deviantart. Yeah, sure. There's a lot of spriters who makes a WHOLE character if you tell them so. Of course.

I may not be liking the guy's work(because I don't like it, even I love SE/ SC), but I'm not coming here to say "your work is X", or "you suck". He said (in the first post?) that he doesn't wants feedback which, in my humble opinion is THE WORST you can do for a project you're working at. But, hey! I respect his decission not blaming the guy. So, your reply to this topic is...empty. Some people said things(yeah!) but at least they're not using THAT tone of you.

Thx man

that's also my point of view..i've been too rude for such a hard work...

Next time maybe Lr or Hr or Filtered.... hope the final version will impress me much...

but for now too bad.......

i'm not a coder and not designer nor creator...and always expecting much more than a poor human being, like my friend could do...so...a great sorry, and don't be too disappointed for some poorless mind.

i'm a great fan of soul calibur and always bought my famous games...that wouldn't be your case.... i think...maybe i'm wrong...

anyway fade up with those demo... i will wait for a real and enhanced game...if not....the story will teach us that i was right...

bye bye

and for the others enjoy this fine demo of ....

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#35 January 13, 2014, 06:19:17 pm

I know what you mean Eliott...but please don't be too rude... ok it is a fact that the creator haven't took time to finalize is work. And maybe i will for the future.

I know such as many player and mugeners here you were so dissapointed that you'd tried to awaken the creator, in order he gave us the best for the next time.

I totally agree with you... but it was maybe a first try for him...not so bad, but not very good. but a try anyway.

so every one should stay calm and wait for better days and an enhanced version of what should be a great mugen.. if...

Eliott you should help him, by filtering his chars..as i know you can do it...and have the skills to do so..

peace !!!

Shin Mako

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

#36 January 14, 2014, 12:16:03 am

I'm working alone if you want to help me then quit complaining and help
lots of people want to complain and not even help me I'm doing this alone
like anyone here would care

Lord Kain

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

New #37 January 14, 2014, 12:30:16 am

Vae Victus!

eliott said, January 13, 2014, 12:24:42 pm

This is MUGEN a fighting game engine for people who are dedicated to take their own time to make free characters and stages for others to use, you want perfection? then play the original game, you're just another user here and by the way you're acting no one its gonna take you seriously , no one here has to "impress you", matter fact no one will pay attention to you, the only attention you are get its from the admins of this forum and im sure they will "impress you" so hopefully next time you think twice before you make another moronic post.

"Given the choice; whether to rule a corrupt and failing empire or to challenge the Fates for another throw a better throw against one's destiny... what was a king to do?

Last Edit: January 14, 2014, 12:38:56 am by Lord Kain

Links to this post

Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A (Read 7348 times)

Markpachi

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

~Hale "R@CE" Caesar~

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Saikoro

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

HUNGRY WOLF

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

[DKG]

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Basara Dandy

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Romeotantan

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Jmorphman

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

abls1

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

JackTheAwkward

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

FeLo_Llop

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Human

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

eliott

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Shin Mako

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A

Lord Kain

Re: Soul Edge 2 Demo 1.0 A