He's pretty fun. I didn't really fire SF4 for comparisons so I'm going from memory and feel on some things here. Gouken was the only char I mained in SF4, not that I played it very long.

- I think you should destroyself the angled Hadouken if it leaves the top of the screen, so he can fire another one
- Too much startup on his overhead
- Too little startup on far hard kick
- Far light kick doesn't look like it should be rapid fire. Close could be, though
- Fireball Clsn2's look mismatched with the sprites
- On that note, the fireballs seem to linger for a few frames after being hit by other fireballs
- He can dive kick from a back jump
- Back throw should have more startup. It's how they balanced its uniqueness in SF4. I think the tech window was longer than normal too
- I think missed throw attempts should have more recovery. I'm guilty of that too but at least I can blame SFA3
- Normal fireballs seem very small spritewise
- Kung Fu Man can crouch under Hadouken
- EX Hadouken doesn't have the charging sound. On that not why not use Gouken's own? I think he had one at least
- Tatsumaki spin sounds don't sound good. All versions. On a related note I don't know why people removed the shared channel in the "whiff" sounds
- Neutral hop attacks should use the animation for angled jump attacks
- Demon flip vels feel weird. Admittedly that may just be me. The throw follow-up definitely looks different, though
- His regular and MAX supers are all very samey
- Both MAX supers should have a bit more invulnerable frames
- I miss his Shin Shoryuken hit sounds
- EX Hadouken charge effect is smaller than the regular version
- I think back throw should not have selectable direction. Doesn't feel right and it's confusing. I think P2 goes too high as  well
- I think full Denjin Hadouken would feel better if the wall bounce had the typical velocities
- Denjin Hadouken (no charge) has too much startup. No need because it's not an ultra anymore
- I think you should pack more damage in the first hit of Shoryuken so that cancelling it into Tatsumaki does more total damage
- Related to the above, but MAX Shinkuu Tatsumaki needs to juggle better. He has no usable "Dream" cancels otherwise
- Not your fault but close hard kick custom combo looks comical, hehe. Like Chun-Li's Hyakuretsu
- Senkugoshoha looks weird because he only punches after losing all momentum
- Shin Shoryuken should be unblockable after the freeze
- I don't like that you made angled jumping MP juggle in tight combos but not in the combos where it's supposed to

Hope it helps.

I wonder what'll the difference be of this version vs. Varo Hade's version.

The only feedback I have is that he seems to have no voice clip upon (regular) K.O.

- He has no KO sound, as the sound is group 11 index 1, instead of 11, 0, and there is no code to activate it.

- Sakotsu Wari is listed as F + b, while I think you meant F + y.
- Tenmakujinkyaku is listed as DF + k, but I can do it with just D, and only with MK, not all kicks.
- In the Move Details section, Tatsumaki Gorasen is listed as being both upper body invincible and fully invincible, I think you meant EX Tatsumaki Gorasen is fully invincible.

- The AI will often charge Gohadouken when in a good distance from the opponent, and will not fire it until is too late, resulting in spamming projectiles being a cheap and easy way to win against him: https://streamable.com/gjvka7

- I think you should destroyself the angled Hadouken if it leaves the top of the screen, so he can fire another one

- Too much startup on his overhead

- Too little startup on far hard kick

- Far light kick doesn't look like it should be rapid fire. Close could be, though

- Fireball Clsn2's look mismatched with the sprites

- On that note, the fireballs seem to linger for a few frames after being hit by other fireballs

- He can dive kick from a back jump

- Back throw should have more startup. It's how they balanced its uniqueness in SF4. I think the tech window was longer than normal too

- I think missed throw attempts should have more recovery. I'm guilty of that too but at least I can blame SFA3

- Normal fireballs seem very small spritewise

- Kung Fu Man can crouch under Hadouken

- EX Hadouken doesn't have the charging sound. On that not why not use Gouken's own? I think he had one at least

- Tatsumaki spin sounds don't sound good. All versions. On a related note I don't know why people removed the shared channel in the "whiff" sounds

- Neutral hop attacks should use the animation for angled jump attacks

- Demon flip vels feel weird. Admittedly that may just be me. The throw follow-up definitely looks different, though

- His regular and MAX supers are all very samey

- Both MAX supers should have a bit more invulnerable frames

- I miss his Shin Shoryuken hit sounds

- EX Hadouken charge effect is smaller than the regular version

- I think back throw should not have selectable direction. Doesn't feel right and it's confusing. I think P2 goes too high as  well

- I think full Denjin Hadouken would feel better if the wall bounce had the typical velocities

- Denjin Hadouken (no charge) has too much startup. No need because it's not an ultra anymore

- I think you should pack more damage in the first hit of Shoryuken so that cancelling it into Tatsumaki does more total damage

- Related to the above, but MAX Shinkuu Tatsumaki needs to juggle better. He has no usable "Dream" cancels otherwise

- Senkugoshoha looks weird because he only punches after losing all momentum

- Shin Shoryuken should be unblockable after the freeze

- I don't like that you made angled jumping MP juggle in tight combos but not in the combos where it's supposed to

- Various hitboxes like those of the high Hadoukens and EX Tatsumaki Gorasen are too thin and whiff on certain characters if their hurtboxes are too small.

- The Fully Charged Diagonal Hadoukens lack some transparency.

- The EX Flash Sound cuts off for EX Hyakkishu's followups.

- Hyakki Gosai doesn't do real damage (only 7 per hit).

- EX Kongoshin could do with a tad more damage.

- Why not give Shinkuu Tatsumaki a voice clip? He does already have a Tatsumaki Senpukyaku voice at the ready.

- The wind effect on his fully charged hadoken is so subtle that I can't notice, however the upwards versions lacks transparency.
Other than that people already pointed some other things that I noticed.

+ I just noticed a wrong color In his stance animation, it's between his belt and top gi, it's noticeable with his alternate palettes.

-I don't like the idea of having a 2nd hitbox near his legs on his standing, crouching and get hits as certain moves can hit certain places where it shouldn't.

-His taunt doesn't have a landing effect and envshake when he stomps the ground like Senkugoshoha.

-Raikotokyaku uses a normal ground shockwave instead of a strong one when he slams the opponent to the ground and has a strong punch hit sound when there was no hitspark.

-The projectile hit sound will still play one tick after if it was parried.

-The swing sound on Hyakki Gojin cuts off when he touches the ground.

-Kongoshin doesn't have a voice clip when countering.

-The EX sound on EX Kongoshin cuts off when he successfully counters an attack.

-On EX Tatsumaki Senpukyaku, he moves so fast when you press forward, but so slow when press backwards (The speed should be even for both directions).

-If you managed to get the back leg of EX Tatsumaki Senpukyaku to connect, a hit sound will be heard, but no hitspark or guard spark will appear.

Admittedly, it's been a while since I've played Gouken in SF4, but the damage of his demon flip grab doesn't seem right, as it barely does any.

His crouching MK barely has any reach at all. I know it wasn't great in SF4, either, but it seems kind of exaggerated here.

He's also missing a few sprites, or rather, he sometimes transforms into Ryu. This can be seen when he's thrown by another Gouken's P throw.

His fully charged LP hadoken also doesn't have the darker swirl around it. This is also true for the horizontal EX hadoken.

Edit: He could also need some adjustments to his width during some of his attacks (like his close MK or close HK): https://streamable.com/f0mxdq

Another thing I noticed: The alternate version of his Shin Shoryuken (the one without the full animation) is just a single hit attack that does very little damage. Maybe that was intentional, but it wasn't like that in SF4 and feels pretty underwhelming considering it's still a level 3 super.

Oh, and no focus attack? Even without its original game mechanic (and command, obviously), it could still be a nice special similar to Ryu's donkey kick.

If you skip the intro, the sound clip still plays.
To prevent that, you should add a StopSND in State -2 or -3 with the trigger1 = RoundState != [0,1].

The charge sound effect for the Hadoukens remains if Gouken gets hit.

The LVL3 Shin Shoryuken can be ground-recovered.

The only feedback I have is that he seems to have no voice clip upon (regular) K.O.

- He has no KO sound, as the sound is group 11 index 1, instead of 11, 0, and there is no code to activate it.

- Sakotsu Wari is listed as F + b, while I think you meant F + y.
- Tenmakujinkyaku is listed as DF + k, but I can do it with just D, and only with MK, not all kicks.
- In the Move Details section, Tatsumaki Gorasen is listed as being both upper body invincible and fully invincible, I think you meant EX Tatsumaki Gorasen is fully invincible.

- The AI will often charge Gohadouken when in a good distance from the opponent, and will not fire it until is too late, resulting in spamming projectiles being a cheap and easy way to win against him: https://streamable.com/gjvka7

- I think you should destroyself the angled Hadouken if it leaves the top of the screen, so he can fire another one

- Too much startup on his overhead

- Too little startup on far hard kick

- Far light kick doesn't look like it should be rapid fire. Close could be, though

- Fireball Clsn2's look mismatched with the sprites

- On that note, the fireballs seem to linger for a few frames after being hit by other fireballs

- He can dive kick from a back jump

- Back throw should have more startup. It's how they balanced its uniqueness in SF4. I think the tech window was longer than normal too

- I think missed throw attempts should have more recovery. I'm guilty of that too but at least I can blame SFA3

- Normal fireballs seem very small spritewise

- Kung Fu Man can crouch under Hadouken

- EX Hadouken doesn't have the charging sound. On that not why not use Gouken's own? I think he had one at least

- Tatsumaki spin sounds don't sound good. All versions. On a related note I don't know why people removed the shared channel in the "whiff" sounds

- Neutral hop attacks should use the animation for angled jump attacks

- Demon flip vels feel weird. Admittedly that may just be me. The throw follow-up definitely looks different, though

- His regular and MAX supers are all very samey

- Both MAX supers should have a bit more invulnerable frames

- I miss his Shin Shoryuken hit sounds

- EX Hadouken charge effect is smaller than the regular version

- I think back throw should not have selectable direction. Doesn't feel right and it's confusing. I think P2 goes too high as  well

- I think full Denjin Hadouken would feel better if the wall bounce had the typical velocities

- Denjin Hadouken (no charge) has too much startup. No need because it's not an ultra anymore

- I think you should pack more damage in the first hit of Shoryuken so that cancelling it into Tatsumaki does more total damage

- Related to the above, but MAX Shinkuu Tatsumaki needs to juggle better. He has no usable "Dream" cancels otherwise

- Senkugoshoha looks weird because he only punches after losing all momentum

- Shin Shoryuken should be unblockable after the freeze

- I don't like that you made angled jumping MP juggle in tight combos but not in the combos where it's supposed to

- Various hitboxes like those of the high Hadoukens and EX Tatsumaki Gorasen are too thin and whiff on certain characters if their hurtboxes are too small.

- The Fully Charged Diagonal Hadoukens lack some transparency.

- The EX Flash Sound cuts off for EX Hyakkishu's followups.

- Hyakki Gosai doesn't do real damage (only 7 per hit).

- EX Kongoshin could do with a tad more damage.

- Why not give Shinkuu Tatsumaki a voice clip? He does already have a Tatsumaki Senpukyaku voice at the ready.

- The wind effect on his fully charged hadoken is so subtle that I can't notice, however the upwards versions lacks transparency.
Other than that people already pointed some other things that I noticed.

+ I just noticed a wrong color In his stance animation, it's between his belt and top gi, it's noticeable with his alternate palettes.

-I don't like the idea of having a 2nd hitbox near his legs on his standing, crouching and get hits as certain moves can hit certain places where it shouldn't.

-His taunt doesn't have a landing effect and envshake when he stomps the ground like Senkugoshoha.

-Raikotokyaku uses a normal ground shockwave instead of a strong one when he slams the opponent to the ground and has a strong punch hit sound when there was no hitspark.

-The projectile hit sound will still play one tick after if it was parried.

-The swing sound on Hyakki Gojin cuts off when he touches the ground.

-Kongoshin doesn't have a voice clip when countering.

-The EX sound on EX Kongoshin cuts off when he successfully counters an attack.

-On EX Tatsumaki Senpukyaku, he moves so fast when you press forward, but so slow when press backwards (The speed should be even for both directions).

-If you managed to get the back leg of EX Tatsumaki Senpukyaku to connect, a hit sound will be heard, but no hitspark or guard spark will appear.

Admittedly, it's been a while since I've played Gouken in SF4, but the damage of his demon flip grab doesn't seem right, as it barely does any.

His crouching MK barely has any reach at all. I know it wasn't great in SF4, either, but it seems kind of exaggerated here.

He's also missing a few sprites, or rather, he sometimes transforms into Ryu. This can be seen when he's thrown by another Gouken's P throw.

His fully charged LP hadoken also doesn't have the darker swirl around it. This is also true for the horizontal EX hadoken.

Edit: He could also need some adjustments to his width during some of his attacks (like his close MK or close HK): https://streamable.com/f0mxdq

Another thing I noticed: The alternate version of his Shin Shoryuken (the one without the full animation) is just a single hit attack that does very little damage. Maybe that was intentional, but it wasn't like that in SF4 and feels pretty underwhelming considering it's still a level 3 super.

Oh, and no focus attack? Even without its original game mechanic (and command, obviously), it could still be a nice special similar to Ryu's donkey kick.

If you skip the intro, the sound clip still plays.
To prevent that, you should add a StopSND in State -2 or -3 with the trigger1 = RoundState != [0,1].

The charge sound effect for the Hadoukens remains if Gouken gets hit.

The LVL3 Shin Shoryuken can be ground-recovered.

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- Too much startup on his overhead

Off the top of my head, both Gouken's and Ryu's overheads in SF4 are 17f. In CvS2, Ryu's overhead is 28f in Normal Speed, which should translate to about 21f in Turbo (the default and competitive setting of the game). Gouken's overhead matches that startup.

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- Far light kick doesn't look like it should be rapid fire. Close could be, though

Far Light Kick does rapid fire in USF4
https://streamable.com/aommj4
Close Light Kick doesn't.

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- On that note, the fireballs seem to linger for a few frames after being hit by other fireballs

It might be because it causes more hitstun than a regular Hadoken. 2f to be precise. If it's more than 2f please let me know because I might not be reproducing the bug correctly.

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- Normal fireballs seem very small spritewise

Its the same size as Shakunetsu which is similarly sized to regular Hadoken.

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- I miss his Shin Shoryuken hit sounds

The USF4 ones?

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- Related to the above, but MAX Shinkuu Tatsumaki needs to juggle better. He has no usable "Dream" cancels otherwise

Yeah, it was source accurate up until now, but I'm definitely improving its juggles. It won't mean Gouken has usable MAX cancels tho, as the dampener makes it so its never worth doing Kinjite->Shinku Tatsumaki over Denjin or ShinSho (and I'm ok with that, I want for Gouken's lv.3s to be the money makers).

PotS said, March 25, 2022, 09:42:30 pm

- I don't like that you made angled jumping MP juggle in tight combos but not in the combos where it's supposed to

Addressed on Discord already but it's working as it should:
https://streamable.com/b0l6au

Having the input from a Gouken main is really helpful.