News:

MFG's Character of the Month: October 2026 Voting

Main Menu

Feedback please.

Started by TITAN MADRE, February 26, 2013, 03:17:20 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

TITAN MADRE



Be honest, what can you say about this. Looks like pro or not. why? im going in a wrong way? need your help because dont have any feedback in other place. Dont be nice. Be honest please.

Jango

If you're going for cartoony, it looks great! The dragon's head looks like it's been vertically squished, though.

Titiln

the entire upper part of the dragon looks squished imo.  the rest is really good though, you did very good with the hair texture and the dragon's scales

TITAN MADRE

Now you two said it (squish effect)...Yes its true and i dont see it. Ill take in count to look more carefully the entire picture the next time.
So, you think is good enought to be considerated "good work". Thank you very much. Its really hard to me find feedback on devianart or pixiv because the world its too big and after 30 scond after upload a pic, 50 other guy put they stuff pushing down mine :(

Titiln

i crudely photoshopped what i think the dragon would look like nonsquished

Iced

its stylized but not bad at all!
Its pretty interesting visually, only the dragon skull looks off.

The dragon body shapes on the background could use some small details here and there so they dont look as cylindrical.

TITAN MADRE

You are right Titiln, my problem was, i guess, drawed at a4 area trying to use all empty space. But not is a excuse, my mistake was look to close, see parts and not the entire picture.
I think your solution make the draw more strong.

Iced, yes,  i admit i was lazy to make those details...i use the concept: "the background its not the sale area" so leave blurry and unfinished.
You really feel the pic lose "something" without those extras? if you are a client, you buy it anyway or not?

This particular peace, is good enough for japanese, america, europe market? is "pro" enough? or need a lot of more hard work?
(no ego from. is just a honest naive question and need a true hard answer).

Iced

the style in the backdrop its good as concept art, it sells the idea pretty well, but as artwork adding at least a bit of detail is better even for things not in the main view, anything that would break the lines back there would solve it easily.

AlexSin


TITAN MADRE

Thanks iced. A litle more extras. ok.
Thanks again for those honest and usefull feedbacks :D

Close the topic.