Hitbox Discussion I guess

Started by TheFclass97, May 23, 2017, 04:43:13 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

TheFclass97



Thoughts? I decided to ask some people to make their versions of this normal (standing lp) and compare how we do our hitboxes. I was bored...

Note:

- Fixed Midori's to his newest version.
- Added Answers version

The Answer


TheFclass97

Ohh, interesting.... gonna add that to the main post.

Iced

wouldnt it make sense to share a clean pic so that people could draw hitboxes over?

TheFclass97

Enjoy???



When's the Melee hitboxes?

R565

I agree, and I also see what people priorities are. Man everyone does theirs differently, but same at the same time.

Kamekaze

Yamori's is the best. 2nd being zanqueef. Original is fine depending on how fast it is. If its really fast you want blue over read otherwise yamori is good. It's important to note that hit boxes are not about matching the sprite, it's the utility of the move itself.

Edit: I was focused on the upper half of which zanqueef is very much off the mark. You want something like fclass midori or yamori for the hurboxes. the hitboxes see my previous response.
Want to feel useful for a useless show? click here
119/150 Chars, I'm not dead yet....the true surprise is in my thread.
Hahahah fuck you photobucket.

Warden-San

Iroha stripped for me

Dumanios


Bastard Mami

Quote from: Kamekaze on May 23, 2017, 05:10:56 AM
it's the utility of the move itself.

and this is why I don't like having the static picture only, I ahve no idea how the hand got there, for all I know, that's  a taunt and the hitbox should be in the finger.

Xinos


TheFclass97

I'm at work right now, but I'll be sure to post some other stuff like gifs and maybe other moves if ya'll are interested. I'll also update the posts when I'm off, because this is getting fun and interesting... Cool stuff guys :D

Ricepigeon

Gonna echo what [E] and Kamekaze said; I have no idea how the hand got there, without the rest of the animation or knowing the move's purpose I can't make a proper judgement of the hitboxes. Perhaps the biggest question (original animation notwithstanding): is it an anti-air or not?

DelusionTrim

I'm no character maker but here is my try (note: I don't like the idea of AA-jabs [with the exception of very few characters], so yeah :S):



PS: looking at it again I would probably increase her arm hurtbox downward a bit.
(DeviantART) - Ignore my username on DA as it was made long before I learned what the fanbase was like...

JustNoPoint


Memo

Quote from: Just No Point on May 23, 2017, 09:23:40 PM

WORK OF ART

The hitbox on the tit is too op high priority, you gotta take that one off to make her tournament legal

Byakko

That's an anti-sexual abuse defense. There's a mouse trap in there.
If I struggled to the end of my determination, to the end of my way of life with my followers, if the result is ruin, then this ruin is inevitable. Grieve. Shed tears. But you cannot regret.

R565



TheFclass97

Wow, such a good hitbox. I'll update the first post later, but let's try something else (this time with animations!)

This is a standing Medium Attack from Uino (by Drowin).

Animation:



Original Hitbox:



Blank Version:



My version:



Hope we get some interesting versions here since well... it's weapons this time.