CvSvC

Started by │ㄷ ▌, May 18, 2009, 09:17:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

extravagant

UMT Season #2 - 2nd Place
UMT Season #3 - 1st Place
CvS2 vs POTS Season #1 - 1st Place
NorCal Crab Battle CvS2 - 2nd Place

Jesuszilla

Quote from: டுந்க்ற்க்ţ on February 11, 2014, 04:25:22 AM
Yes, she isn't.

But I think she fits in that sheet more then in any other.
Put her in Capcom. She does not belong there.

Titiln

tabasa shouldn't be in the darkstalkers category because she's not a darkstalkers character at all. shantae is not a capcom character but i think i've mentioned this 20 times by now.

Drex

If we are going to be strict about this then Sakura, Karin, & Rolento need to be in the SF section and the CvS & SvC sections need to go away entirely since it just contains random Capcom or SNK characters which should be covered by the ACTUAL Capcom and SNK sections. It's not a big deal to me wether our not this stuff gets fixed though.

inktrebuchet

#244
I never realized I only favor KOF or CPS3 style until I saw them all lumped together like this.


Jesuszilla

Quote from: Titiln on February 11, 2014, 08:13:06 PM
tabasa shouldn't be in the darkstalkers category because she's not a darkstalkers character at all. shantae is not a capcom character but i think i've mentioned this 20 times by now.

That too.

Quote from: Drex on February 11, 2014, 08:34:45 PM
If we are going to be strict about this then Sakura, Karin, & Rolento need to be in the SF section and the CvS & SvC sections need to go away entirely since it just contains random Capcom or SNK characters which should be covered by the ACTUAL Capcom and SNK sections. It's not a big deal to me wether our not this stuff gets fixed though.

He keeps adding to ONE big image, so it shouldn't be that hard to take the piece and then move it.

│ㄷ ▌

Quote from: extravagant on February 11, 2014, 12:07:21 PM
Can someone do a Goddess Athena?? :D

She is the 3rd char in SNK sheet




I know Tessa is from Red Earth/Warzard, but I think Red Earth and Darkstalkers share the medieval scheme and the use of "mystical" creatures, powers and such.

I let her there also because there aren't that much chars in DS sheet, just compare the sheet sizes and they are named as DS to generalize.

Most of chars in CAP sheet are modern and futuristic.

The sheets' organization can be flexible, I said in the FAQ that this is nothing official so I can take some liberties to select and organize the chars as I feel to.

I'm not going to erase Shantae, I already did her sprites, think of her as a "guest" char (thinking about it I could move her to DS sheet, maybe Ruby Heart too) :P


There are some notes in the FAQ that explain my choices. Plus, I have played all the official fighting games, I know their rosters, I searched all around the web to find the best sprites done by the people and I did a lot of sprites by my side, so you can trust my decisions.

And don't let that my choices bother you. Isn't like if owe you something, Im not CAPCOM/SNK, I did this for fun in my free time and I wanted to share it.  :cool2:






walt

#247
Then call it Chamat's Sprite Encyclopedia. The current name sounds very official, and since your work and research is very exhaustive, maybe that's why people feel it should be more official/canon/universal than just your personal choices.

If you clarify right off the bat in the name it will help people to expect ... less (?) out of it, and bother you less as well.



Also, you've always been confused about this term. The images, drawings, digital art ... are called a SPRITE, like the beverage.


A Spriter is the artist.

│ㄷ ▌

Pfff do you think I don't know what's the difference between spriter and sprite?

I named it as spriteRS because I wanted to focus in the people that did the images more than in the characters, Im a person that likes to give credit, and I conceived it as from the community for the community.

What's the deal if I show it with quality? it doesn't make it official, I always said that, THIS IS NOTHING OFFICIAL don't you get it or what?

I won't change it to Chamat's Spriters encyclopedia, I would be taking all the credit of something that was done by a lot of people. (Do you know what a book's editorial is? Yes? Well, think of me as the editorial)

We are in the same level, none of us have official powers, so don't talk me like if you were somebody official ok?

Sorry if I sound rude, but this is bullshit, if you don't get the point of the whole encyclopedia due some details, you are free to don't use the sheets or you can do your own encyclopedia if it bothers you so much.


...That's why I did the FAQ, it seems like you talk about "important issues" without having read it, and I mention all of it in the FAQ.


Ahh yeah and THIS IS NOTHING OFFICIAL:

Quote
-Disclaimer: This encyclopedia shows the most accurate edits according to a personal opinion, that doesn't mean that these are the definitive/final/official ones. So you are free to judge/use by your own will.






walt

Wow, 14 lines of text. I didn't mean to make you mad, it was a suggestion for your convenience (see the "bother you less as well" part!)

I just try to make my posts as clear and serious as possible so people know I'm interested in the topic. I'm sorry if my formal way of posting bothers you, but I'm not changing that.

Spoiler: Sprite-Spriter (click to show)
The difference between sprite and spriters is something I observed long ago, I just pointed it out until today. I'd even try to dig it up from your post history but, if I recall correctly, you deleted a good portion of your legacy on a whim some months ago.

You even made that mistake in the Spanish Only thread. That made me suspect you really had no grasp of the concept ... but if you say you do, that's Ok :P

AlexSin

Quote from: walt on February 12, 2014, 04:56:37 PM
Also, you've always been confused about this term.
I think you're confusing Chamat with zero de armentis.

walt

It may be the case. I'll look into it. If that's the case, I apologize for the confusion.

│ㄷ ▌

It's ok.

You are confusing me with Armentis (or CVSNB), but come on, one thing is confusing words (something that I didn't) and other one is confusing people and throwing accusations without having any proof. So be careful with that, you deserved my rage post.

Anyway everything is clear, I hope. About the fact that you people order me to do this or that, I won't obey if you don't convince/persuade me, so no, Im not going to obey Jesuszilla or Titiln or anybody without an excelent argument or that make me note my mistakes, again, Tessa's & Shantae organization is because flexibility, but are not errors.

It is good that you show some interest and want to get involved, but that's not the way to get involved, in the FAQing FAQ I explain how :P (doing sprites for example)

And I mean this could be the best encyclopedia about sprites you will find, we took the time with eFeX to do it like that, the other ones I know are:
[Sprite Edit]
[body no dot image]
*Orochinagi had a good gallery but it is down
*There are some in DA too


(I know that I erased my posts, but I just erased the useless ones):llama:

I would like to keep helping with the sheets but I don't have so much time, so it depends on you.

Vemos






Titiln

Quote from: டுந்க்ற்க்ţ on February 14, 2014, 09:06:43 PM
Im not going to obey Jesuszilla or Titiln or anybody without an excelent argument or that make me note my mistakes, again, Tessa's & Shantae organization is because flexibility, but are not errors.
what better argument do you want for tessa than "she's not a darkstalkers character" or "she's not a capcom character" for shantae? to anyone that knows about games, the way they currently are makes no sense. nobody's going to look into this thing and say "hmm i wonder what tessa would look like in different sprite styles, i'm going to look in the darkstalkers category because she looks like a darkstalkers character". it's not practical to the viewer at all

Jesuszilla

Chamat, you need to stop being overly defensive and just do what makes sense. What you're doing makes no sense.

walt

Quote from: டுந்க்ற்க்ţ on February 12, 2014, 06:23:43 AM
I know Tessa is from Red Earth/Warzard, but I think Red Earth and Darkstalkers share the medieval scheme and the use of "mystical" creatures, powers and such.

I let her there also because there aren't that much chars in DS sheet, just compare the sheet sizes and they are named as DS to generalize.

Most of chars in CAP sheet are modern and futuristic.
These aren't necessarily Darkstalkers, but like Tesssa, I think they could also fit well in the Darkstalkers Section. Also, Tessa and these guys should go at the bottom of the DS sheet, not at the top or in between the maing characters of the Canon storyline.




[Judas]

While the whole thing is a great idea, I have to agree about the random categorization being highly annoying. If it's to focus on the artists and not the sprites themselves, two things should probably be changed:
-dump the categories-by-series in lieu of something like categories-by-theme; I don't recall beating Pyron with Tabasa/Tessa.
-add in an appropriate apostrophe. Spriters' or Spriter's, depending on whether or not you want plural. As it is named now, it is implied to be an encyclopedia of spriters. Something showing the works as categorized by artist. I'd probably still throw your name at the front of it as suggested.

Also, Shantae being involved with this Capcom/SNK thing at all has been bothering me since the beginning. Might as well throw Billy and Jimmy LeeLewis in the Street Fighter or KoF categories. I know sprite conversions to those styles exist.

Spoiler: But if you want to do it right... (click to show)

-Violent Ken should be in the CvS category. I assume characters that are in the crossover games are why it even exists; V. Ken isn't in anything BUT a crossover, an honor he shares with God Rugal.
-Street Fighter EX characters shouldn't count. I don't care about personal preferences; they are not owned by Capcom.
-Sakura and Karin aren't Street Fighter, now? News to me.
-Shun from the Alpha movie? Really?
-Enough characters for a Rival Schools category.
-Enough characters for a Final Fight category.
-Now that I'm looking at it, several characters are absent from the crossover categories.
-Probably enough for a Resident Evil category, but they're fine where they are.
-Again, Tabasa/Tessa. If anything, she should probably be in the crossover category thanks to SvC.
-The CvS sprite of Lao is not by Kiwi. It's a so-so edit of his Street Fighter I Birdie. Not bad, but certainly not up to his standards.
-Goenitz, Rugal, and Orochi in the AoFF (a.k.a. Southtown) category? That's... Ridiculous.
-The Metal Slug subsection should prooooobably be in the SNK general category instead of KoF.
-Samurai Shodown, Last Blade, Savage Reign/Kizuna Encounter, and World Heroes all have enough for their own categories, but I can see why you might leave a few of them in the SNK general section.

Some of that is general nitpicking, some of it is glaring oversights/faults that make no sense to me whatsoever.

│ㄷ ▌

ok, then I think the DS name should be changed, as I said Warzard and Darkstalkers are alike, the problems are:
-DS sheet is supposed to be the "mystical or ancient" themed games from CAPCOM, like Red Earth, King of dragons, Knights of the round, Dynasty Wars, and so on... (Even if the sprites aren't created I'm saving them that sheet)
-DS sheet is small, and it is because it was focused in DS chars mostly, but all the other sheets share more then one title: SF:1-2-3-4-EX, (EX shouldn't be included but it was), AOFF: AOF+FF+(KoF), KOF:94-95-96-97-98...+XIII, NGBC:Last Blade+Samurai Shodown... it is the same for the other sheets, adding multiple titles that have multiple versions that bring a lot of new chars, so doing DS sheet exclusively for DS char seems poor because they aren't that much, there are just like 3 titles with (most of) the same chars in all of them, so I add more, but I called it DS because Darkstalkers is the most popular serie in it.

So if you throw a logical name it can be changed, remember that it is supposed to be "mystical/medieval/ancent" for CAPCOM titles.



Yes Walt has a point about moving those ones, these even are at CAP' sheet' bottom because I think these don't fit with other titles there, but these are popular by it's own, unlike Red Earth (it is popular but not THAT POPULAR), anyway I think I can move them.



CvS and SvC show the most important chars from CAPCOM & SNK mostly:

Quote
Q:What is the order of the sheets?
A:-CvS: CAPCOM characters that officially appeared in "SNK vs Capcom Chaos"
  -SvC: SNK characters that officially appeared in "Capcom vs SNK" 1 & 2

(CAPCOM side)
  -SF: Street Fighter series characters
  -CAP: CAPCOM characters from another series
  -DS: Darkstalkers series characters

(SNK side)
  -AOFF: Art of Fighting, Fatal Fury, Garou Mark of the Wolves series characters
  -KOF: King of Fighters series characters
  -SNK: SNK characters from another series

But in the notes I state this:
Quote
-Even if Demitri, Tessa, Zero, Violent Ken & Red Arremer officially appeared in "SNK vs Capcom Chaos", Haohmaru & Hibiki in "Capcom vs SNK 2" they aren't in the CvS and SvC sheets because they clash with the other chars in those sheets.

And if you wonder
Quote
Q:Why there are not included some chars of CAPCOM or SNK?
A:Because they lack to have sprites of them in more than one style. Or are not in 2d sprites yet, or the sprites that exist dont have a good quality.



3 of 4 points clear. About Shantae, it doesn't hurt nobody or not many people care about if she is there, I mean yes, she is from Wayforward, she isn't CAPCOM's the game was just published for them, but come on what do you expect? that I erase those sprites? I was fooled like believing she was CAPCOM's, just look at the GBC cover, Im pretty sure Im not the only one, and even when I knew she wasn't from them I still like her, so don't insist you aren't going to convince me. Remember that one of the points about the whole encyclopedia is to bring bases that can become mugen chars, so Imagine a full playable Shantae.

She is an isolated case, and it is an Extra if you think about it. I really don't see the problem with her.

The same could happen with Mighty No 9, Fat-Megaman(He is CAPCOM's but I don't take him seriously), Toro & Kuro and some other chars, they can be guests here.


It is not like if I were adding chars from Tekken/DOA/SoulCalibur or another game from another known/popular company or any OC, doing so would be an error.



About being defensive it was mostly because I explained in the FAQ why I did that structure that has a logic by it's own, I undestand that you don't share that idea, but you were pushing me too much in a thing that it is not that important for most of us, the Index is still there, so you can find any char you want even if the organization isn't the one you like. (I could mix them by gender/race/age... and it will still have a logic or I could randomize them and as long the Index is there you can find them)

Yeah I thought you were nitpicking too much for something dispensable/not important, but what Walt did has a logic and I accept that suggestion, so this discussion was good.

And Jesuszilla or anyone who likes to, I will wait what new name you come up with for DS sheet.(2-4 letters)

Again I say it is good that all of you want to get involved because it is from the community for the community, but I didn't expect you would come up with the organization topic (I still think it is dispensable, because it's my logic):P, honestly I was expecting just new sprites. But I will make the "necessary" changes when I have time.

Vemos






Jesuszilla

Why would there need to be a new name? Just remove Tabasa from the DS sheet and put her in the Capcom sheet. How hard is it?


And who is "most of us"? The only one who seems to think how you do is... well, you. And ONLY you. Everyone else is telling you to organize things better.

Iced

After seeing the argument I decided to check out what you were all talking about. I dont understand the cvs division.  It has chars like hugo there, but then there is a section for street fighter and there is no ryu in there.

Chamat, a suggestion, focus on a denomination for those divisions, be it game of origin or company of origin or whatever. and go with it. Having a chunli in street fighter and one in Cvs and evil ryu in street fighter but ryu in cvs makes little sense.