Nice work so far. Some quick notes to keep you busy.

System:
- The presentation and general feel of the game are excellent
- Music is too loud compared to sound effects. I know you can change that, but still
- Round start screen takes too long
- Every stage should use the same zoom, boundaries, etc parameters
- Every character should use the same input system
- Parry detection Clsn1 should be as big as the character's respective Clsn2 (most people seem to get this one wrong)
- The cost of Rage moves could be recoverable damage. Feels wrong to not get a Perfect win if you use them (c.f. Focus Attacks)
- Hitdef yaccel should be consistent throughout the game. For instance Tiger Uppercut seems floatier than Shoryuken

Ryu:
- Hadouken recovery feels too fast
- Tatsumaki travel distance seems short
- Taunt voices might work better the other way around
- Hadouken Clsn1 is too big. Use this rule of thumb: if the opponent can't neutral jump over the slow version of the projectile, the hitbox is too big
- Fireballs disappear before crossing the edge of the screen
- EX Tatsu dust vertical position is not constant
- Looks like all versions of Shoryuken have the same invulnerability

Ken:
- His Hadouken is better than Ryu's (outside this game). I get the feeling you decided to buff every projectile in the game, but still feel like I should point it out
- Tatsumaki is punishable on hit

Akuma:
- Voice is lower than other characters
- Killing Vega intro in regular matches (i.e. not boss fights) seems weird

Dan:
- Walk speed seems too low
- Does his Rage move do anything besides taunting? Seems like a mean handicap
- Crouching medium kick can't cancel into Dankukyaku. There may be more stuff like this because I didn't go over every cancel/special combination
- Jump is too low. Although you could pass that as an SNK parody

Charlie:
- Character width constants are larger than the Clsn2

Guile:
- Jump feels floatier than other characters

Chun-Li:
- I'm rusty on this kind of details, but her Kikouken seems way, way better than usual
- I know she's Chun-Li, but the walk speed feels too fast

Sagat:
- Crouch parry detection is huge. Make it around the kness or so for everyone (with standing parry picking up where it ends)
- What's that ghost hitbox after projectiles connect?
- Hitboxes look stronger than other characters
- F+A moves him too far forward, then too far back

Bison:
- Psycho Power punch effects are misaligned
- Back dash should be statetype = A

Ingrid:
- Walk speed feels even faster than Chun-Li

Note:
- Feedback for each character might apply to other characters, especially shoto stuff

Regarding the fireballs, I'm just comparing them to Street Fighter games. Making them stronger here may actually be a clever idea because the game has Parry.

RagingRowen said, February 17, 2022, 08:41:16 pm

I'm not sure about Ken's Hadouken being better in the source games as you said because I thought I made his the worst in this.

Oh, I meant that Capcom Ryu's Hadoukens are worse than RagingRowen Ken's Hadoukens. But see the point above.

You will not use the old stance?